The best City Keeper and worst

Best-Marshall,Alexander

Worst- Bywater useless

Marshall is the best keeper we have had in my lifetime, always like Hallworth too. Neil Alexander was massively over rated imo, as soon as he had to leave his line and claim a cross or command the 18 yard box he would look lost and flap around.

God there's been so many bad keepers in recent years, Enckleman, Warner, Bywater, Dimi, Ross Turnbull. Jeeeeeeez quite depressing really

Best - Ron Healy -andy Dibble
Worst - Peter Grotier - Bywater

However I could have adde somemore shit ones Dimi, Warner, Zois I watched some shit keepers in my time!!!!

Tough one this. This is sure to stretch fans thoughts

I'll start with best - Neil Alexander ( very underrated). Worst - Peter Zois

Yes!Neil Alexander.Best.Peter Zois.Worst.

Thinking about this over lunch....

I haven't see George Wood mentioned as the best so far so i'll add him to the list.


Geroge Wood George Wood Georgie Gerogie Wood he's got no hair but we don't care georgie Georgie Wood

Best: Farquashon Worst: Bywater

Really interesting how many people going for ward
No votes for schmeichael is a suprise aswell

Really interesting how many people going for ward
No votes for schmeichael is a suprise aswell

Probably because Schiemchal didn't stay long. But everyone or just me would remember the terrible keepers even if they didn't stay for long e.g Bywater.

ron healey was 2nd choice keeper at man city behind the legendary joe corrigan. He joined us when we were utter shyte and kept us in numerous games we had no right to get anything out of. For that reason he was the best we've ever had.

Too many crap ones to mention sorry.

ron healey was 2nd choice keeper at man city behind the legendary joe corrigan. He joined us when we were utter shyte and kept us in numerous games we had no right to get anything out of. For that reason he was the best we've ever had.

Too many crap ones to mention sorry.

ron healey was 2nd choice keeper at man city behind the legendary joe corrigan. He joined us when we were utter shyte and kept us in numerous games we had no right to get anything out of. For that reason he was the best we've ever had.

Too many crap ones to mention sorry.

Ron Healy was a tidy keeper, Andy Dibble was the best I thought he was going to go further than he did, Peter Grotier was the worst I've seen.

Best - George Wood......Top top keeper, and bald to boot!

Worst - Bywater

Best - Marshall
Worst - Bywater

Tony Warner has got to be there some where as one of the worst

ron healey was 2nd choice keeper at man city behind the legendary joe corrigan. He joined us when we were utter shyte and kept us in numerous games we had no right to get anything out of. For that reason he was the best we've ever had.

Too many crap ones to mention sorry.

Totally agree Ron Healey was class

My first post on this message board and I go back a long way! Fred Davies was a great goalkeeper for the City as was Bill Irwin. Andy Dibble was without doubt the best home produced keeper. Ron Healy was a City legend!

Best - Marshall is better than Alexander. That's why he's playing in the Prem and the highest Alexander played was Chamionship with us, still a great stopper though.


Worst - agent Dimi. Or Bywater. Enkleman was pretty shit mind

UEFA Cup final..?