Is Gestede good enough?

Can't believe so many are having a go at a player that when he has come on this has done well for us, ok todays goal was a tap in but Rudy was in the right place to do it. And at the end of the day that goal won us the 3pts, he is a Cardiff City player support him

This is honestly pathetic.

Your talking like we are in the bottom 12.

RUDY IS A USELESS STRIKER, HE IS THE REASON FOR OUR BAD FORM

F**king grow a set some of you.

This is honestly pathetic.

Your talking like we are in the bottom 12.

RUDY IS A USELESS STRIKER, HE IS THE REASON FOR OUR BAD FORM

F**king grow a set some of you.

He has become an obsession for some fans it seems

First start in ages, did ok, scored the only goal of the game and got us 3 points and thread after thread about him

He is good enough to be part of a promotion chasing team? Hes in one ffs.

This is honestly pathetic.

Your talking like we are in the bottom 12.

RUDY IS A USELESS STRIKER, HE IS THE REASON FOR OUR BAD FORM

F**king grow a set some of you.

It's pathetic having a go at him after every game, in Malky we trust and he picks him when he doesn't then he is not good enough

He ent cost defeats.

This is honestly pathetic.

Your talking like we are in the bottom 12.

RUDY IS A USELESS STRIKER, HE IS THE REASON FOR OUR BAD FORM

F**king grow a set some of you.

How dare football fans have a debate

How dare Gestede cost us winning 9 points.

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

Such an insightful post

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

Any one could've scored that goal

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

Such an insightful post

Thank you

Gestede is doing perfectly fine for us this season

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

Any one could've scored that goal

Why didn't anyone? Bellamy had better chances, hardly a clear cut chance.

Looking at it again on the football league show its because he wanted it more than the defender and finished well.

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

Any one could've scored that goal

Why didn't anyone? Bellamy had better chances, hardly a clear cut chance.

Looking at it again on the football league show its because he wanted it more than the defender and finished well.

Because Rudy's a striker, he's meant to be there to score goals. I agree that Bellamy had better chances, but Bellamy's always in the right place at the right time to get those chances, he just needs to finish them.

I know he scored the only goal yesterday but that one goal isn't going to change my mind on him, he had an awful game, but no one really had a good game. We need someone better.

Of course we need better.

He still did a job and though and with the options we have he was the right choice and finished his chance.
If bellers was more alert earlier on as well Rudy have got a assist.


People seem obsessed with rating him as good enough whatever that means. With the options we had today he was the right choice and only player to score.

It's odd he gets so much attention

Well he's good enough to win us 3 pts at this level as it showed today so I said yes, although I agree there is better !

Of course we need better.

He still did a job and though and with the options we have he was the right choice and finished his chance.
If bellers was more alert earlier on as well Rudy have got a assist.


People seem obsessed with rating him as good enough whatever that means. With the options we had today he was the right choice and only player to score.

It's odd he gets so much attention

It just annoys me when people bring him up when he's done something decent and they slate the people who criticise him. For his standards he's getting better, but in reality he's not that good and he's nowhere near the standards of the rest of our squad. That's just my opinion though, I still cheered his goal and chanted "Rudy" at the top of my voice.

Of course we need better.

He still did a job and though and with the options we have he was the right choice and finished his chance.
If bellers was more alert earlier on as well Rudy have got a assist.


People seem obsessed with rating him as good enough whatever that means. With the options we had today he was the right choice and only player to score.

It's odd he gets so much attention

It just annoys me when people bring him up when he's done something decent and they slate the people who criticise him. For his standards he's getting better, but in reality he's not that good and he's nowhere near the standards of the rest of our squad. That's just my opinion though, I still cheered his goal and chanted "Rudy" at the top of my voice.

Sounds about right.
IMO at the moment he is a cert for the bench and after doing well deserves his chance.
He started and scored and that's it. Boy Did good.

I thought he looked poor today, he scored a tap in and then went missing today. He is very static and for a young man he should be putting in a lot more. He won the odd header today and did a few link ups but you would expect that of any player sadly his overall effort and runs are shocking.

I really can't argue with that asessment of things.

Maybe a stint on loan somewhere with regular football would help bring him on a bit but I still haven't seen enough to suggest he is an asset to a team chasing premier league football.

Scoring the only goal of the game, surely makes him an asset.
He isn't the best but ATM the only type of player we have.

And but for poor finishing by them could of cost us the points cos the ball just wont stick to him and often leads t giving possession back to them.

Against better teams his failure to control the ball will cost us.

I thought he looked poor today, he scored a tap in and then went missing today. He is very static and for a young man he should be putting in a lot more. He won the odd header today and did a few link ups but you would expect that of any player sadly his overall effort and runs are shocking.

I really can't argue with that asessment of things.

Maybe a stint on loan somewhere with regular football would help bring him on a bit but I still haven't seen enough to suggest he is an asset to a team chasing premier league football.

Scoring the only goal of the game, surely makes him an asset.
He isn't the best but ATM the only type of player we have.

And but for poor finishing by them could of cost us the points cos the ball just wont stick to him and often leads t giving possession back to them.

Against better teams his failure to control the ball will cost us.

He kept the ball better than Helguson when he came? Yes or no?

He's a donkey. The only "good" thing he can do is win headers but he can't even do that most of the time, and when he does it goes nowhere.

And score winners

Any one could've scored that goal

Why didn't anyone? Bellamy had better chances, hardly a clear cut chance.

Looking at it again on the football league show its because he wanted it more than the defender and finished well.

Hardly a clear cut chance?

Laid on a plate 3 yards out

I thought he looked poor today, he scored a tap in and then went missing today. He is very static and for a young man he should be putting in a lot more. He won the odd header today and did a few link ups but you would expect that of any player sadly his overall effort and runs are shocking.

I really can't argue with that asessment of things.
Maybe a stint on loan somewhere with regular football would help bring him on a bit but I still haven't seen enough to suggest he is an asset to a team chasing premier league football.

Scoring the only goal of the game, surely makes him an asset.
He isn't the best but ATM the only type of player we have.

And but for poor finishing by them could of cost us the points cos the ball just wont stick to him and often leads t giving possession back to them.
Against better teams his failure to control the ball will cost us.

He kept the ball better than Helguson when he came? Yes or no?

Absolutely NOT.

Was begin the defender and moved infront of him during play, quite clear. Many better chances during the game for bellers.

Serious question polo is your obsession with him just you now trying to prove yourself right? You don't seem to grasp anything good he does. Your obviously an intelligent guy and seem the work DJ did (and batter MM for it).
You seem to want to make a point all the time.

Was begin the defender and moved infront of him during play, quite clear. Many better chances during the game for bellers.

Serious question polo is your obsession wHowith him just you now trying to prove yourself right? You don't seem to grasp anything good he does. Your obviously an intelligent guy and seem the work DJ did (and batter MM for it).
You seem to want to make a point all the time.

Not allowed an opinion am I?

I didnt start this thread I gave my opinion same as you did.

I made a point of watching him yesterday and goal aside he was awful. One good lay off and won one header that reached its intended target.

For his size he cant jump, hes weak and the less said about his touch the better.

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

Was begin the defender and moved infront of him during play, quite clear. Many better chances during the game for bellers.

Serious question polo is your obsession wHowith him just you now trying to prove yourself right? You don't seem to grasp anything good he does. Your obviously an intelligent guy and seem the work DJ did (and batter MM for it).
You seem to want to make a point all the time.

Not allowed an opinion am I?

I didnt start this thread I gave my opinion same as you did.

I made a point of watching him yesterday and goal aside he was awful. One good lay off and won one header that reached its intended target.

For his size he cant jump, hes weak and the less said about his touch the better.

Sorry didn't realise I said you weren't allowed an option, thought I asked you a question

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Whittinghams touch was barely golden same as every other player. 2blue is right helguson was certainly less effective when he came on for Rudy

We must have been watching different games

Looks like it Rudy isnt a brilliant player but he does what asked of him and causes problems.