Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:06 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:07 pm
Bakedalasker wrote:Blue_Always wrote:Bakedalasker wrote:mjw6150 wrote:Bakedalasker wrote:What about the existence of Isreal in accordance to the scriptures?
What about it?
Golly surprise with this reply.
Go and purchase "Battle for Isreal" by Lance Lambert.
There was another book worth a read on the same subject but cannot remember its title. It was by an author called Derek Pringle I think. An individual who spent time in Isreal during its many wars. Interesting reads.
Just tell us the crux of the book in relation to this thread, after all you brought it up ffs
Try saying please then FFS.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:08 pm
mjw6150 wrote:Same old arguments...
How come in the first chapter of 'Mein Kampf' Hitler says he is 'doing god's word' and 'executing god's will' by destroying the Jewish people?
Hitler wrote this book in the 1920s and was trying to appeal to the large Catholic population of Germany. He quickly began persecuting the Catholic Church once in dominant power. Mein Kampf never says anything about destroying Jews either, it might be derogatory about them but it doesn't go that far.
Furthermore, the first treaty made by the Nazi's was with the Vatican. Allowing Catholic control of German education.
A treaty they very quickly broke.
Worst of all, the Catholic Church celebrated the birth of the Fuhrer every year until his death in 1945.
Evidence? Pretty sure they weren't a fan (if they ever were) once he began throwing Bishops in Concentration Camps.
May I ask, what the bloody hell does phone-hacking, the NHS and the expenses scandal have to do with religious belief? These events involved both religious and non-religious people! Are you suggesting that those events somehow represent atheism?
You are missing the point, the other posters state how all this immorality is down to religion, yet there is whole world of stuff that isn't from religion.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:10 pm
Blue_Always wrote:Bakedalasker wrote:Blue_Always wrote:Bakedalasker wrote:mjw6150 wrote:Bakedalasker wrote:What about the existence of Isreal in accordance to the scriptures?
What about it?
Golly surprise with this reply.
Go and purchase "Battle for Isreal" by Lance Lambert.
There was another book worth a read on the same subject but cannot remember its title. It was by an author called Derek Pringle I think. An individual who spent time in Isreal during its many wars. Interesting reads.
Just tell us the crux of the book in relation to this thread, after all you brought it up ffs
Try saying please then FFS.
Pwetty Pwease
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:10 pm
greenlawler wrote:OhhhGa wrote:Blue_Always wrote:DamnRightIveGotTheBlues wrote:Why do you have to go after religion? It gives people comfort; it doesn't hurt anything." Okay, well, other than most wars, the Crusades, the Inquisition, 9/11, arranged marriages to minors, blowing up girls' schools, the suppression of women and homosexuals, fatwas, ethnic cleansing, honor rape, human sacrifice, burning witches, suicide bombings, condoning slavery, and the systematic f*cking of children, there's a few little things I have a problem with
If you honestly believe all those atrocities are caused by religion and not mans capacity to self destruct then i think you really ought to have a deeper look at human beings, observe how religious individuals conduct themselves. I don't remember Joe Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pott, ever espousing religious views. And what about the the nastiness in mid staffs NHS trust, journalists hacking the phone of murdered children, MPs exspenses , Are these your poster boys for modern atheism?
Although the above list is actually a quote from Bill Maher, those events were all certainly caused by religion. Some are still on going, such as the suppression of women, institutionalised paedophilia, and the vilification of homosexuals for example, whereas others serve as horrific reminders of the potency of religious doctrine.
The 'Hitler was an Atheist' line is an absolute classic and always makes me laugh (and cringe).
How come in the first chapter of 'Mein Kampf' Hitler says he is 'doing god's word' and 'executing god's will' by destroying the Jewish people?
How come the oath that every Nazi soldier had to take, began with 'I swear in the name of almighty god my loyalty to the Fuhrer'?
How come on the belt buckle of every Nazi soldier were the words 'God on our side'?
Furthermore, the first treaty made by the Nazi's was with the Vatican. Allowing Catholic control of German education.
Worst of all, the Catholic Church celebrated the birth of the Fuhrer every year until his death in 1945.
Let me move on to your other examples.
May I ask, what the bloody hell does phone-hacking, the NHS and the expenses scandal have to do with religious belief? These events involved both religious and non-religious people! Are you suggesting that those events somehow represent atheism?
You are a confused individual with ludicrous and muddled arguments.
I am not a fan of "organized religion" as well. Implying Christians today share the blame for the Crusades and Hitler's atrocities is pathetic.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:16 pm
Blue_Always wrote:mjw6150 wrote:Same old arguments...
How come in the first chapter of 'Mein Kampf' Hitler says he is 'doing god's word' and 'executing god's will' by destroying the Jewish people?
How come the oath that every Nazi soldier had to take, began with 'I swear in the name of almighty god my loyalty to the Fuhrer'?
How come on the belt buckle of every Nazi soldier were the words 'God on our side'?
Hitler wrote this book in the 1920s and was trying to appeal to the large Catholic population of Germany. He quickly began persecuting the Catholic Church once in dominant power. Mein Kampf never says anything about destroying Jews either, it might be derogatory about them but it doesn't go that far. The other acts I have never heard of before but likely were to gain Catholic support also. I bet they weren't done as fiercely once the persecution of the Church began.
Furthermore, the first treaty made by the Nazi's was with the Vatican. Allowing Catholic control of German education.
A treaty they very quickly broke.
Worst of all, the Catholic Church celebrated the birth of the Fuhrer every year until his death in 1945.
Evidence? Pretty sure they weren't a fan (if they ever were) once he began throwing Bishops in Concentration Camps.
May I ask, what the bloody hell does phone-hacking, the NHS and the expenses scandal have to do with religious belief? These events involved both religious and non-religious people! Are you suggesting that those events somehow represent atheism?
You are missing the point, the other posters state how all this immorality is down to religion, yet there is whole world of stuff that isn't from religion.
Good post, i have not read mein kampf, but i know that Hitler didn't use monotheism directly and to my knowledge was not a devoutly religious man, The reference to 'god' on nazi insignia is vague, as god can take many forms, hardly a stick to beat the bible with, unless the bible teaches facism.
How do you know the catholic church did not temper Hitlers aggresion as part of a deal? If a deal was indeed struck it was probably done reluctantly, What else could organised religion do in the face of a murdering tyrant?
The phone hacking and everything else is evidence of amoral vacum mate, we have never been more atheist, so yesi'm blamming atheism for this mess, what do you think is the reason?
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:18 pm
OhhhGa wrote:greenlawler wrote:OhhhGa wrote:Blue_Always wrote:DamnRightIveGotTheBlues wrote:Why do you have to go after religion? It gives people comfort; it doesn't hurt anything." Okay, well, other than most wars, the Crusades, the Inquisition, 9/11, arranged marriages to minors, blowing up girls' schools, the suppression of women and homosexuals, fatwas, ethnic cleansing, honor rape, human sacrifice, burning witches, suicide bombings, condoning slavery, and the systematic f*cking of children, there's a few little things I have a problem with
If you honestly believe all those atrocities are caused by religion and not mans capacity to self destruct then i think you really ought to have a deeper look at human beings, observe how religious individuals conduct themselves. I don't remember Joe Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pott, ever espousing religious views. And what about the the nastiness in mid staffs NHS trust, journalists hacking the phone of murdered children, MPs exspenses , Are these your poster boys for modern atheism?
Although the above list is actually a quote from Bill Maher, those events were all certainly caused by religion. Some are still on going, such as the suppression of women, institutionalised paedophilia, and the vilification of homosexuals for example, whereas others serve as horrific reminders of the potency of religious doctrine.
The 'Hitler was an Atheist' line is an absolute classic and always makes me laugh (and cringe).
How come in the first chapter of 'Mein Kampf' Hitler says he is 'doing god's word' and 'executing god's will' by destroying the Jewish people?
How come the oath that every Nazi soldier had to take, began with 'I swear in the name of almighty god my loyalty to the Fuhrer'?
How come on the belt buckle of every Nazi soldier were the words 'God on our side'?
Furthermore, the first treaty made by the Nazi's was with the Vatican. Allowing Catholic control of German education.
Worst of all, the Catholic Church celebrated the birth of the Fuhrer every year until his death in 1945.
Let me move on to your other examples.
May I ask, what the bloody hell does phone-hacking, the NHS and the expenses scandal have to do with religious belief? These events involved both religious and non-religious people! Are you suggesting that those events somehow represent atheism?
You are a confused individual with ludicrous and muddled arguments.
I am not a fan of "organized religion" as well. Implying Christians today share the blame for the Crusades and Hitler's atrocities is pathetic.
I am not suggesting that. I am refuting the idea that Hitler was an atheist in any form. I also believe it is pathetic to use Hitler as an argument AGAINST atheists, do you not?
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:20 pm
Blue_Always wrote:OhhhGa wrote:greenlawler wrote:OhhhGa wrote:Blue_Always wrote:DamnRightIveGotTheBlues wrote:Why do you have to go after religion? It gives people comfort; it doesn't hurt anything." Okay, well, other than most wars, the Crusades, the Inquisition, 9/11, arranged marriages to minors, blowing up girls' schools, the suppression of women and homosexuals, fatwas, ethnic cleansing, honor rape, human sacrifice, burning witches, suicide bombings, condoning slavery, and the systematic f*cking of children, there's a few little things I have a problem with
If you honestly believe all those atrocities are caused by religion and not mans capacity to self destruct then i think you really ought to have a deeper look at human beings, observe how religious individuals conduct themselves. I don't remember Joe Stalin, Hitler, Pol Pott, ever espousing religious views. And what about the the nastiness in mid staffs NHS trust, journalists hacking the phone of murdered children, MPs exspenses , Are these your poster boys for modern atheism?
Although the above list is actually a quote from Bill Maher, those events were all certainly caused by religion. Some are still on going, such as the suppression of women, institutionalised paedophilia, and the vilification of homosexuals for example, whereas others serve as horrific reminders of the potency of religious doctrine.
The 'Hitler was an Atheist' line is an absolute classic and always makes me laugh (and cringe).
How come in the first chapter of 'Mein Kampf' Hitler says he is 'doing god's word' and 'executing god's will' by destroying the Jewish people?
How come the oath that every Nazi soldier had to take, began with 'I swear in the name of almighty god my loyalty to the Fuhrer'?
How come on the belt buckle of every Nazi soldier were the words 'God on our side'?
Furthermore, the first treaty made by the Nazi's was with the Vatican. Allowing Catholic control of German education.
Worst of all, the Catholic Church celebrated the birth of the Fuhrer every year until his death in 1945.
Let me move on to your other examples.
May I ask, what the bloody hell does phone-hacking, the NHS and the expenses scandal have to do with religious belief? These events involved both religious and non-religious people! Are you suggesting that those events somehow represent atheism?
You are a confused individual with ludicrous and muddled arguments.
I am not a fan of "organized religion" as well. Implying Christians today share the blame for the Crusades and Hitler's atrocities is pathetic.
I am not suggesting that. I am refuting the idea that Hitler was an atheist in any form. I also believe it is pathetic to use Hitler as an argument AGAINST atheists, do you not?
Ok Provide us with evidence that hitler was devoutly religious man enacting the good work set out by Jesus. The Nazi used religious verse as political slogans but do you honestly think priests were holding court reading mein kampf to their flock?Everything in his life suggests was more atheist than believer.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:24 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:28 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:29 pm
greenlawler wrote:Ohhgaa I never did imply he was. I do not think Christians, should allow ourselves to think anyone responsible for evil, and great evil t that may have not done it in the name of a greater power, i.e. Crusades, 9/11, Spanish Inquisition, etc.... My point is that too many Anti-Christians use examples like Hitler to somehow say Christianity is at fault. Clearly it is the misguided actions of misguided men.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:31 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:34 pm
Blue_Always wrote:He was not religious, He was acting like a man with no consience or any fear of the after life, to me that holes him in the atheist camp. Yet strangely you reject him as yours
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:46 pm
OhhhGa wrote:Blue_Always wrote:He was not religious, He was acting like a man with no consience or any fear of the after life, to me that holes him in the atheist camp. Yet strangely you reject him as yours
He was acting in the name of God if you take his own words. He felt that God was on his side. I have been over this and will not go over it again.
You are clearly incapable of understanding that Hitler was neither religious nor an atheist.
Your are clearly incapable of understanding that even if Hitler WAS a self-proclaimed atheist, this would offer absolutely nothing to your argument.
You are desperate, you are pathetic, and you are discrediting those who are sensible in their belief.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:50 pm
Blue_Always wrote:OhhhGa wrote:Blue_Always wrote:He was not religious, He was acting like a man with no consience or any fear of the after life, to me that holes him in the atheist camp. Yet strangely you reject him as yours
He was acting in the name of God if you take his own words. He felt that God was on his side. I have been over this and will not go over it again.
You are clearly incapable of understanding that Hitler was neither religious nor an atheist.
Your are clearly incapable of understanding that even if Hitler WAS a self-proclaimed atheist, this would offer absolutely nothing to your argument.
You are desperate, you are pathetic, and you are discrediting those who are sensible in their belief.
I'm remaining very dignified here, i don't take hitler by his word, you clearly do, and then you call me pathetic?
Fri Apr 05, 2013 4:55 pm
OhhhGa wrote:greenlawler wrote:Ohhgaa I never did imply he was. I do not think Christians, should allow ourselves to think anyone responsible for evil, and great evil t that may have not done it in the name of a greater power, i.e. Crusades, 9/11, Spanish Inquisition, etc.... My point is that too many Anti-Christians use examples like Hitler to somehow say Christianity is at fault. Clearly it is the misguided actions of misguided men.
Of course. Men who are unique, and thus unique in their views, both religious and non-religious.
It does however, annoy me when religious people (like the ignorant poster above) wheel out the 'Hitler was an atheist' argument as if that somehow discredits atheism itself! Firstly, he clearly wasn't, and almost all historians agree that he was a man of muddled faith. Secondly, he is one man unique to history. Finally, if we're arguing over which atrocities were religious/non-religious then there will only be one victor.
I think it smacks of desperation when someone says 'this dictator believed this' in an argument on religion. More so when they're actually wrong.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 6:13 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 6:26 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 7:12 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 7:46 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 8:38 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 8:48 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 8:53 pm
All Black Everything. wrote:NJ73, Jim Jeffries is the best comedian by a mile. Steve Hughes is another quality comedian.![]()
Fri Apr 05, 2013 10:57 pm
Fri Apr 05, 2013 10:59 pm
All Black Everything. wrote:The Lord of the Rings or Harry Potter will become a religion sooner or later. To be fair there is a lot more factual information in those two series of books than in any religious book that has come out of Christianity or Islam.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 11:00 pm
JONNY012697 wrote:I wouldnt bother listening to OOH I got it wrong again.
Despite being told to the contrary he spouts the same stuff over and over again, hes like a broken record, unwilling to listen to any other argument. Take his drivel that the Catholic Church despises homosexuals, ive explained the churches position on homosexuality at least 3 times now at which point he stops posting because he cant debate my reasoning, yet guaranteed thinking people have have short memories he repeats the exact same stuff in the exact same scripted way.
I will give you an example oh his 'superior' intellect. Ohhgaa believes people who follow organised religion are weak willed individuals who cling on to the idea of an after life because unlike people of his superior intellect cant cope with death. Implying that he is vastly superior than unintelligent bible wielding lesser beings.
I have never heard such bigoted uneducated ridiculous drivel but will he listen no, will he take anybodies opinion on board other than his own no.
I refuse to debate him AGAIN as he lacks any debating skill with the mentality of im right your wrong and thats it.
so there is no point.
Here is the wikipedia article on the church and hitler read it and take from it what you will
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catholic_C ... zi_Germany
Hitler was not a practicing Catholic despite being raised a Catholic
The Waffen-SS the Nazi wing of the military did not follow organised religion and created their own religion
The Wehrmacht the conventional armed forces of Germany did.
The Waffen-SS were responsible for the holocaust the Wehrmacht were not.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-rel ... 3573/posts
the Catholic Church fought against the Nazis pre-war and during to the point when the whole of Europe was under the tyrannical grip of Hitler on man stood against him Pope Pius XII thats one lonely figure from a very small city state.
Ohhgaa will not listen or read any of this information because it doesnt suit his opinion.
However each to their own and hopefully this young man will learn the skills of debate and rational thinking and learn that despite his opinion people have other opinions and there is a chance that they may have a point.
No doubt he will try to discredit me however I dont care.
Remember this though most of what he posts about religion is just hate filled bile
Fri Apr 05, 2013 11:00 pm
Bridgend_bluebird wrote:The day religion gets abolished, is the day the human race can move on.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 11:15 pm
mjw6150 wrote:
Because God is the only possible cause.
Fri Apr 05, 2013 11:16 pm
NJ73 wrote:mjw6150 wrote:
Because God is the only possible cause.
How do you know?
Fri Apr 05, 2013 11:18 pm
mjw6150 wrote:NJ73 wrote:mjw6150 wrote:
Because God is the only possible cause.
How do you know?
Universal, unchanging and immaterial laws can only be accounted for by a universal, unchanging, immaterial being who is eternal.
God is those things.