Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

" SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:24 pm

For the blip we have had over the last few weeks, do you blame the players, the manager or the board or all three.?

What do you think is the answer to our problems,and please dont say Earnie. :roll:

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:25 pm

Kenny Miller.

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:26 pm

nobby wrote:For the blip we have had over the last few weeks, do you blame the players, the manager or the board or all three.?

What do you think is the answer to our problems,and please dont say Earnie. :roll:

The Carling Cup got into their heads, and the hangover hasn't gone yet :(

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:27 pm

wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:28 pm

wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.

Miller plays alone on the pitch :shock:

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:29 pm

nobby wrote:For the blip we have had over the last few weeks, do you blame the players, the manager or the board or all three.?

What do you think is the answer to our problems,and please dont say Earnie. :roll:


From the outside looking in, I would blame the Cup final. I think it's a mentality problem right now, something along the lines of one or two players thinking they are better than they are because they raised their game against Liverpool and ran them close.

From what I read on here and the couple of games I have seen you play, work rate was a big part of your game and it seems to be missing?

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:31 pm

Mainly the manager's tactics.
Can't fault effort from the players, and the board have backed Malky from the start. Even more so once we reached the final.

Sure Malky has been great so far, and connected us all. But I think it's entirely his fault that the players are burnt out.
He encourages non-stop working hard (which isnt really a bad thing) but its taking its toll on the players. Also his favouritism plays a big part. He has his 'golden boys' such as Turner, Cowie, Whitts, Mason, Rudy, Kenny. When we have other capable players such as Earnie, Naylor, Quinn, Kiss, Conway, Ralls, Blake, Keinan etc..
For the run-in he should definitely be using some of these players, just to take a little bit off the regulars so they can recover some of their past form

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:33 pm

wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


:roll: Sensible replies only please

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:33 pm

Dave Jones :problem:

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:35 pm

LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:


No, his job is to score goals, and he aint doing it, 11 games now and 2 penalty`s missed..

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:38 pm

If anyone due to the carnage he left...... Dave Jones.

Malky had nothing to start with this season except half a dozen suspect defenders.

It was encouraging early doors, he now knows what its like at a sleeping giant :lol: :lol: :lol:

next season is his season, the players are bought, sold and coached by the manager. Of course he has financial restrictions, as do all managers, but Leicester couldn't buy their way out of the championship and we couldn't loan our way out last season, so lets hope he find the magic potion.

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:38 pm

wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:


No, his job is to score goals, and he aint doing it, 11 games now and 2 penalty`s missed..


Even if he was scoring, the defense need to keep goals out. So no, kenny isn't to blame. The defense is.

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:40 pm

You only have to look at Birmingham city last season to see that the CCF didn't help, & the way we lost the final aswell took a lot mentaly out of our players, none more so than Kenny Miller. Will the guy ever take a penalty for City again? Given the chance i know i would trust him to do so, just to get the monkey off his back, but its a big ask.

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:40 pm

LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:


No, his job is to score goals, and he aint doing it, 11 games now and 2 penalty`s missed..


Even if he was scoring, the defense need to keep goals out. So no, kenny isn't to blame. The defense is.


But you dont win games if you dont score goals...Its Millers fault.

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:43 pm

nobby wrote:For the blip we have had over the last few weeks, do you blame the players, the manager or the board or all three.?

What do you think is the answer to our problems,and please dont say Earnie. :roll:


The manager is too Blame.

He picks the team. He dictates the tactics..

Just wish he would use the squad.

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:54 pm

fatigue

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 5:59 pm

wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:


No, his job is to score goals, and he aint doing it, 11 games now and 2 penalty`s missed..


Even if he was scoring, the defense need to keep goals out. So no, kenny isn't to blame. The defense is.


But you dont win games if you dont score goals...Its Millers fault.


You don't win games of you don't keep a clean sheet. Miller isn't the only way we can score. Stop being so blind

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:06 pm

Fatigue amongst the team is causing a lot of this

Greater use of the squad would help over the 90 mins

Would not dare to blame any individuals WE ARE A CLUB and share responsibility

KEEP THE FAITH - COS I WILL

:ayatollah: :ayatollah: :old:

Re: SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME??

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:07 pm

LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:Kenny Miller.


Yes because he's conceding the goals :roll:


No, his job is to score goals, and he aint doing it, 11 games now and 2 penalty`s missed..


Even if he was scoring, the defense need to keep goals out. So no, kenny isn't to blame. The defense is.


But you dont win games if you dont score goals...Its Millers fault.


You don't win games of you don't keep a clean sheet. Miller isn't the only way we can score. Stop being so blind


Of course you do..2-1..3-1..etc etc..

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:15 pm

So if we leak goals then we are guaranteed to win just because we can score?
Never mind the mental affects of going a goal or two or 3 behind.
Did you think Basil stood a chance after conceding 7 to Bayern Munich? No. They tried parking the bus to stop an even more embarrassing defeat.

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:17 pm

Byewater :evil: :evil:

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:18 pm

LWay wrote:So if we leak goals then we are guaranteed to win just because we can score?
Never mind the mental affects of going a goal or two or 3 behind.
Did you think Basil stood a chance after conceding 7 to Bayern Munich? No. They tried parking the bus to stop an even more embarrassing defeat.


Its simple maths mate all you gotta do is score one more than you concede, and the jobs a good un.. :mrgreen:

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:20 pm

wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:So if we leak goals then we are guaranteed to win just because we can score?
Never mind the mental affects of going a goal or two or 3 behind.
Did you think Basil stood a chance after conceding 7 to Bayern Munich? No. They tried parking the bus to stop an even more embarrassing defeat.


Its simple maths mate all you gotta do is score one more than you concede, and the jobs a good un.. :mrgreen:


Tell that to the city side that lost 6-0 to Preston and see how well it works :lol:

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:25 pm

25% the cup. 25% tactics, failure to utilise the squad,formation,etc and 50% the Tories

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:28 pm

We have a small knackered squad (legs and brains) which needs rotating more.

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:31 pm

LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:So if we leak goals then we are guaranteed to win just because we can score?
Never mind the mental affects of going a goal or two or 3 behind.
Did you think Basil stood a chance after conceding 7 to Bayern Munich? No. They tried parking the bus to stop an even more embarrassing defeat.


Its simple maths mate all you gotta do is score one more than you concede, and the jobs a good un.. :mrgreen:


Tell that to the city side that lost 6-0 to Preston and see how well it works :lol:


But we didn`t score one more than we conceded in that game.. ;)

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:42 pm

wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:
wkdblue wrote:
LWay wrote:So if we leak goals then we are guaranteed to win just because we can score?
Never mind the mental affects of going a goal or two or 3 behind.
Did you think Basil stood a chance after conceding 7 to Bayern Munich? No. They tried parking the bus to stop an even more embarrassing defeat.


Its simple maths mate all you gotta do is score one more than you concede, and the jobs a good un.. :mrgreen:


Tell that to the city side that lost 6-0 to Preston and see how well it works :lol:


But we didn`t score one more than we conceded in that game.. ;)

We did score though! In the wrong goal but still :lol:

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 6:58 pm

nobby wrote:For the blip we have had over the last few weeks, do you blame the players, the manager or the board or all three.?

What do you think is the answer to our problems,and please dont say Earnie. :roll:

Although i think the fact that our main striker isnt scoring is the main problem, that doesnt mean i blame him, there's a big difference!

we're a team, in this together, and when one of our players is out of form then everyone needs to help him through it as best they can!

and we dont have any better options than him right now anyway

i still think think he's the best striker we've had in years :ayatollah:

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 7:07 pm

Who do i blame
At No 1
The Players..............At the end of the day its them on the pitch
Malky.....................He picks the team he motivates them, he signs players
The Fans................. For getting on the players backs to quickly
The Jacks................. For being in the Prem and its making our supporters desperate for promotion.

Re: " SO WHO DO YOU ALL BLAME?? "

Wed Mar 14, 2012 7:07 pm

I blame Mackay for picking the same team and formation week in week out and not utilising the Transfer market more successfully