Wed Jan 15, 2020 1:45 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 1:59 pm
Forever Blue wrote:Now Swansea after Chelsea loanee Connor Gallagher.
Jacks already have Brewster and Guehi from Liverpool and Chelsea.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:06 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:09 pm
eddiep wrote:if you were a manager or agent where would you want to place a player.
Cardiff or Swansea?
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:30 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:44 pm
nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:52 pm
pembroke allan wrote:eddiep wrote:if you were a manager or agent where would you want to place a player.
Cardiff or Swansea?
Daft question as we are not looking for young reserve players!
Wed Jan 15, 2020 2:54 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 3:08 pm
phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 3:22 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 3:43 pm
davids wrote:Don't know why everybody thinks that we are long ball merchants and the JB's are a silky pass and move outfit.
Possession on Sunday was 50/50 wasn't it?
![]()
Wed Jan 15, 2020 3:53 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 4:14 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 5:25 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:14 pm
Llan_Blue wrote:pembroke allan wrote:eddiep wrote:if you were a manager or agent where would you want to place a player.
Cardiff or Swansea?
Daft question as we are not looking for young reserve players!
Those three players are better then half our squad ffs!
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:19 pm
pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:27 pm
dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Charlton are struggling mate.. that's the reason..
1 win out of their last 15 games...would you want a player on loan there ?
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:40 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:40 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Charlton are struggling mate.. that's the reason..
1 win out of their last 15 games...would you want a player on loan there ?
Maybe so but as long as getting game time should it matter as they play good football anyway? But as we are not privy to reason for recall we can only speculate? Could be your reason or could be Charlton not playing him and swansea have him with stipulation he plays x amount games?
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:47 pm
Llan_Blue wrote:phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wait what![]()
Coming from the guy who thinks our academy is full of championship level talent, Liverpool and Chelsea’s isn’t guaranteed to have decent players
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:50 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Charlton are struggling mate.. that's the reason..
1 win out of their last 15 games...would you want a player on loan there ?
Maybe so but as long as getting game time should it matter as they play good football anyway? But as we are not privy to reason for recall we can only speculate? Could be your reason or could be Charlton not playing him and swansea have him with stipulation he plays x amount games?
Wed Jan 15, 2020 6:59 pm
bluesince62 wrote:Llan_Blue wrote:pembroke allan wrote:eddiep wrote:if you were a manager or agent where would you want to place a player.
Cardiff or Swansea?
Daft question as we are not looking for young reserve players!
Those three players are better then half our squad ffs!
?? How does that equate? 2 are un tested,the 3rd I agree with you,would improve our midfield greatly. You could be right in a couple of years with the 1st 2,but as of yet they are reserve players at their parent clubs.![]()
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:04 pm
dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Charlton are struggling mate.. that's the reason..
1 win out of their last 15 games...would you want a player on loan there ?
Maybe so but as long as getting game time should it matter as they play good football anyway? But as we are not privy to reason for recall we can only speculate? Could be your reason or could be Charlton not playing him and swansea have him with stipulation he plays x amount games?
its out there but was pretty obvious mate..no its not it doesn't matter, of course it matters who the hell wants a kids development being losing every week.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:06 pm
phildavies wrote:Llan_Blue wrote:phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wait what![]()
Coming from the guy who thinks our academy is full of championship level talent, Liverpool and Chelsea’s isn’t guaranteed to have decent players
You really doesn’t actually pay any attention to what people write do you. I have never said it is full of champ talent I have said that we wrongly let our most talented youngsters go without giving them a chance and instead waste millions on average old men.
And yes loads of shot players come through big clubs academies. Wether the three Swansea have succed we will have to wait and see but Brewster for example doesn’t impress me one bit the new version of Solanke.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:10 pm
phildavies wrote:Llan_Blue wrote:phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wait what![]()
Coming from the guy who thinks our academy is full of championship level talent, Liverpool and Chelsea’s isn’t guaranteed to have decent players
You really doesn’t actually pay any attention to what people write do you. I have never said it is full of champ talent I have said that we wrongly let our most talented youngsters go without giving them a chance and instead waste millions on average old men.
And yes loads of shot players come through big clubs academies. Wether the three Swansea have succed we will have to wait and see but Brewster for example doesn’t impress me one bit the new version of Solanke.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:14 pm
pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:dogfound wrote:pembroke allan wrote:They have now signed Gallagher on loan from Chelsea another cooper player from England set up! At this rate can call them swangland.....
But strange one as on loan at Charlton but recalled to go straight out again?
Charlton are struggling mate.. that's the reason..
1 win out of their last 15 games...would you want a player on loan there ?
Maybe so but as long as getting game time should it matter as they play good football anyway? But as we are not privy to reason for recall we can only speculate? Could be your reason or could be Charlton not playing him and swansea have him with stipulation he plays x amount games?
its out there but was pretty obvious mate..no its not it doesn't matter, of course it matters who the hell wants a kids development being losing every week.
Ahhhh so teams only want youngsters to play for a winning team? Theres me thinking a loan move was to help their development as players in all sorts of scenarios? But hey oh what do I know.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:15 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:42 pm
Mr Potato wrote:phildavies wrote:Llan_Blue wrote:phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wait what![]()
Coming from the guy who thinks our academy is full of championship level talent, Liverpool and Chelsea’s isn’t guaranteed to have decent players
You really doesn’t actually pay any attention to what people write do you. I have never said it is full of champ talent I have said that we wrongly let our most talented youngsters go without giving them a chance and instead waste millions on average old men.
And yes loads of shot players come through big clubs academies. Wether the three Swansea have succed we will have to wait and see but Brewster for example doesn’t impress me one bit the new version of Solanke.
You have changed your tune. Not so long ago you were busy telling me our squad was the envy of the championship. Now we have wasted millions on average old men. Not too dissimilar to what I have been saying all season. Strange.
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:44 pm
Wed Jan 15, 2020 7:45 pm
phildavies wrote:Mr Potato wrote:phildavies wrote:Llan_Blue wrote:phildavies wrote:nojac wrote:Loan players are all well and good, until they return to their parent club.
It leaves a big gap and players that need replacing.
Unless of course you loan a player that you might buy.
But younger players from big clubs are just a short term fix, also its trying to do something on the cheap.
Their also no guarantee that they are actually any good. As I have said before plenty of shit players have come through big clubs academies.
Wait what![]()
Coming from the guy who thinks our academy is full of championship level talent, Liverpool and Chelsea’s isn’t guaranteed to have decent players
You really doesn’t actually pay any attention to what people write do you. I have never said it is full of champ talent I have said that we wrongly let our most talented youngsters go without giving them a chance and instead waste millions on average old men.
And yes loads of shot players come through big clubs academies. Wether the three Swansea have succed we will have to wait and see but Brewster for example doesn’t impress me one bit the new version of Solanke.
You have changed your tune. Not so long ago you were busy telling me our squad was the envy of the championship. Now we have wasted millions on average old men. Not too dissimilar to what I have been saying all season. Strange.
Another that doesn’t actually read what people say. We do have one of the strongest squads in the championship. It also doesn’t mean we haven’t wasted millions on average old men. Our best players are people we brought in for little or no money.