Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:21 pm

I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:24 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?

If true do the deal ASAP.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:25 pm

norms76 wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?

If true do the deal ASAP.


Agree it would be great bit of business. :thumbright:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:38 pm

Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm

cardiffred wrote:Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet


I would.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:43 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
cardiffred wrote:Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet


I would.




Me too! :thumbup:

Sadly, we had great hopes for the boy Mason (particularly after the great League Cup Final goal versus Liverpool) but he's never really come through

I feel the same about Declan John :cry:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:44 pm

Sven wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
cardiffred wrote:Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet


I would.




Me too! :thumbup:

Sadly, we had great hopes for the boy Mason (particularly after the great League Cup Final goal versus Liverpool) but he's never really come through

I feel the same about Declan John :cry:


Agree.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:50 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
Sven wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
cardiffred wrote:Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet


I would.




Me too! :thumbup:

Sadly, we had great hopes for the boy Mason (particularly after the great League Cup Final goal versus Liverpool) but he's never really come through

I feel the same about Declan John :cry:


Agree.


Id have to say that I dont think Mason will ever be a prolific, 15 goals a season striker, weve seen with watt that mason just isnt quick enough. Id like to see us drop Mason slightly deeper, playing in the hole behind Jones/other big man and watt. All three (in my opinion) look good forwards in this league so why not find a system where they can all play, something like:

Gunnarson

Noone Mason Ralls

Watt Jones

:ayatollah:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:59 pm

cardiffred wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
Sven wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
cardiffred wrote:Id let Mason go on loan there till the end of the season, wouldnt let him go perm just yet


I would.




Me too! :thumbup:

Sadly, we had great hopes for the boy Mason (particularly after the great League Cup Final goal versus Liverpool) but he's never really come through

I feel the same about Declan John :cry:


Agree.


Id have to say that I dont think Mason will ever be a prolific, 15 goals a season striker, weve seen with watt that mason just isnt quick enough. Id like to see us drop Mason slightly deeper, playing in the hole behind Jones/other big man and watt. All three (in my opinion) look good forwards in this league so why not find a system where they can all play, something like:

Gunnarson

Noone Mason Ralls

Watt Jones

:ayatollah:


I don't think Mason will be played their anyway so just move him on.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 4:48 pm

no thanks, give wolves a call see if they're still interested

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 5:00 pm

I don't think Declan has had the same opportunities as Mason has had so it's unfair to compare the two.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 5:01 pm

BluebirdWhitchurch wrote:no thanks, give wolves a call see if they're still interested


:thumbup:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 5:02 pm

noisycat wrote:I don't think Declan has had the same opportunities as Mason has had so it's unfair to compare the two.


Agree but I think Declan should be given a chance on the wing.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 5:40 pm

Declan should either be played on the wing or left midfield,it's unfair to criticise him when he plays full back

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 5:45 pm

noisycat wrote:Declan should either be played on the wing or left midfield,it's unfair to criticise him when he plays full back


Exactly.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:14 pm

If true I wonder if we are better off in terms of salary - will we make a saving with switch ?

if so - good deal

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:19 pm

NIBluebird wrote:If true I wonder if we are better off in terms of salary - will we make a saving with switch ?

if so - good deal


I would think they would be on roughly the same amount so a good deal all round i say. :thumbup:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:47 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?


Its a Big No from me , just buy Watt and keep Mason

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:49 pm

oxfordblue wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?


Its a Big No from me , just buy Watt and keep Mason


I think that would be great replace a mediocre striker for a very good one. :thumbup:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:52 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?



I would take that, I like Joe but he is struggling and he needs to learn the Offside Rule :ayatollah:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 6:58 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
oxfordblue wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?


Its a Big No from me , just buy Watt and keep Mason


I think that would be great replace a mediocre striker for a very good one. :thumbup:


They are both very good players , form is temporary

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:04 pm

bluespeers wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?



I would take that, I like Joe but he is struggling and he needs to learn the Offside Rule :ayatollah:


Yes.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:04 pm

oxfordblue wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
oxfordblue wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:I went on there forum and someone said that we will swap Mason for Watt is on the cards?


Its a Big No from me , just buy Watt and keep Mason


I think that would be great replace a mediocre striker for a very good one. :thumbup:


They are both very good players , form is temporary


Watt is the much better player and Mason will find it more difficult to get into the team so move him on.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:05 pm

I'd give him to Charlton for free and still pay the million for Watt.

Horrifically overrated player, one decent debut season where Miller was doing all the work for him and people seem to think he's the next Messi.

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:08 pm

Aramore wrote:I'd give him to Charlton for free and still pay the million for Watt.

Horrifically overrated player, one decent debut season where Miller was doing all the work for him and people seem to think he's the next Messi.


Well i would rather get much better player for free in return for giving a much less good player away and not pay wouldn't you? :lol:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:10 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
Aramore wrote:I'd give him to Charlton for free and still pay the million for Watt.

Horrifically overrated player, one decent debut season where Miller was doing all the work for him and people seem to think he's the next Messi.


Well i would rather get much better player for free in return for giving a much less good player away and not pay wouldn't you? :lol:


Well that's not very fair on Charlton is it?! :old:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:12 pm

Aramore wrote:
Rydogsccfc wrote:
Aramore wrote:I'd give him to Charlton for free and still pay the million for Watt.

Horrifically overrated player, one decent debut season where Miller was doing all the work for him and people seem to think he's the next Messi.


Well i would rather get much better player for free in return for giving a much less good player away and not pay wouldn't you? :lol:


Well that's not very fair on Charlton is it?! :old:


They are getting a player in return they can't have it both ways. :lol:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:18 pm

Only opinions , but lets have a goal count at the end of the season

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:20 pm

oxfordblue wrote:Only opinions , but lets have a goal count at the end of the season


Ok Watt will get more. :thumbup:

Re: A swap deal with Charlton?

Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:24 pm

Rydogsccfc wrote:
oxfordblue wrote:Only opinions , but lets have a goal count at the end of the season


Ok Watt will get more. :thumbup:


Excellent lets hope they both score loads , for The City that is