Bellamy or Mackay?

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

Malky every time for me, he proved himself

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

Malky every time for me, he proved himself

Agreed, still a legend in my eyes

Wouldn't want malky anywhere near this club.

Bellamy easily.
I'd rather keep Slade than malky.

Malky!

Bellamy.

Slade

Malky or Bellers??

Oh dear!

Bellamy.

Wouldn't want malky anywhere near this club.

Bellamy easily.
I'd rather keep Slade than malky.

May I ask, apart from Malky being sent 3 dodgy texts (probably from Iain Moody), what concrete evidence has actually come out to make you not want Malky anywhere near our club?

I highly doubt Kim Bo-Kyung would have signed for Malky a second time if he was really a racist for instance?

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

Cornelius wasn't playing for us in the Championship you dunce.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

Cornelius wasn't playing for us in the Championship you dunce.

Where did I say Cornelius was playing for us in the Championship?

You're having a mare tonight.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

Cornelius wasn't playing for us in the Championship you dunce.

Where did I say Cornelius was playing for us in the Championship?

You're having a mare tonight.

I was referring to Cornelius and Caulker. Neither of them played for us in the Championship. You then responded by saying that these players won us the Championship. How could they have won us the Championship if they weren't playing for us then? The only person having a mare here is you.

Please explain to me and the rest of us, how Caulker and Cornelius won us the Championship.....

You're yet another person on here that has made an ASSumption and now looks like an ASS.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

Cornelius wasn't playing for us in the Championship you dunce.

Where did I say Cornelius was playing for us in the Championship?

You're having a mare tonight.

I was referring to Cornelius and Caulker. Neither of them played for us in the Championship. You then responded by saying that these players won us the Championship. How could they have won us the Championship if they weren't playing for us then? The only person having a mare here is you.

Please explain to me and the rest of us, how Caulker and Cornelius won us the Championship.....

You're yet another person on here that has made an ASSumption and now looks like an ASS.

You never mentioned either player in your original post! Ignore this guy Ross, plastic fantastic.

You never mentioned either player in your original post! Ignore this guy Ross, plastic fantastic.

Brilliant. Your personal vendetta is so pathetic it begs belief. You've even felt the need to get involved in a conversation I'm having with someone else just to get the attention you crave. Hilarious. Regardless of that fact, an assumption was still made. Thats what happens when you jump down people's throats before assessing all possibilities.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

Cornelius wasn't playing for us in the Championship you dunce.

Where did I say Cornelius was playing for us in the Championship?

You're having a mare tonight.

I was referring to Cornelius and Caulker. Neither of them played for us in the Championship. You then responded by saying that these players won us the Championship. How could they have won us the Championship if they weren't playing for us then? The only person having a mare here is you.

Please explain to me and the rest of us, how Caulker and Cornelius won us the Championship.....

You're yet another person on here that has made an ASSumption and now looks like an ASS.

You clearly stated Malky splashed ridiculous sums of money on mediocre players.

I replied stating Malky won us the Championship title by 8 points, making a lot of money for our club in the process.

Considering Malky built our title winning team largely from scratch (he only had 10 senior players at the club when he took over), gave us the Carling Cup final and playoffs in his first season on a squad largely built from free transfers, won us the title by 8 points when given a bit of backing the following season and then kept us above the relegation zone in the Premiership, despite all of Tan's interference; I am at a loss why you think Malky wasted ridiculous sums of money at our club.

Any money Malky spent during our Premiership season was firstly, money Malky had made for our club himself by taking us to the Premiership in the first place and secondly, our "transfer committee" (Simon Lim at the time) was given the go ahead by Tan to sign off the cheques for every transfer we made, knowing full well what the transfer fee involved for each deal was at the time.

Where have I said Caulker and Cornelius won us the Championship again? I wonder what ASSumptions you're going to come out with next?

Goodnight.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

These mediocre players won us the Championship title by 8 points, gave our club tens of millions of pounds of money from reaching the Premiership and we were never in the relegation zone in the Premiership until Malky got sacked.

1) The two players I was referring to were Cornelius and Caulker - I had no reason to specify any particular player.
2) You responded with (see red text) 'these mediocre players won us the Championship'
3) You assumed that I was on about the players he bought during the Championship season - I wasn't - you were wrong
4) If you had asked 'which players?' then I would have told you and then you wouldn't have made the assumption
5) Thats all there is to it, and its not hard to work out.

Goodnight.

I don't want Malky near the club because he splashed ridiculous sums on extremely mediocre players.

Was medel,caulker,mutch,Campbell mediocre?

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

Malky every time for me, he proved himself

Agreed, still a legend in my eyes

Same here

Malky's record and achievements are there for all to see

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

Malky every time for me, he proved himself

Agreed, still a legend in my eyes

Same here

Malky's record and achievements are there for all to see

Totally agree...Malky is crucified for taking a failed gamble on an up and coming young striker which didn't come off

Medal, Caulker, Mutch and Campbell were all sold for small profits...the transfer fees we paid was never the problem...the problem was that lots of players were given big contracts, bonuses with large agents fees etc which to this day is still hurting the club financially....however these contracts would have been negotiated by the CEO and the board......Why Malky still gets the blame for this is unbelievable !!!!

He got us promoted with a hard working, honest team without actually spending the vast amounts of money many people believe

There are bacteria as yet undiscovered by man that id rather have than Malky "it's Just Banter" Mackay at the club.

Malky - he's proven on the field, whilst Bellers has yet to do anything in the managerial arena.

None of them

Bellamy in the hope of being entertained. I don't want to watch the rubbish that Malky and to a slightly lessor extent Slade served up week after week even if it gets us to the premiership!

Malky :bluebird

Bellamy in the hope of being entertained. I don't want to watch the rubbish that Malky and to a slightly lessor extent Slade served up week after week even if it gets us to the premiership!

So you'd prefer to be bottom half championship playing good football than premiership with Mackay tactics?

If given the choice of Bellamy or the old Malky who would you want to manage us?

Pointless question but Malky.