A SIMPLE YES OR NO

After a rather heated debate with a few Scottish Celtic supporters in pub over weekend
Who solely blame Tan and won't have a word said against Malky.

Had a Tan not interfered and the whole debacle had been avoided,based on just the footie,
With Malky in charge and no diversions would we be a premier side still?

Yes or No


I say No

If it had all been avoided I think we'd have stayed up but as soon as everything started kicking off it made it a lot more difficult

No

Yes, but the damage was already done, before we even kicked a ball in the Premier League.

Yes

Yes

Probably not but we'd have had more fight about us and a better chance

No

yes

No Malky had instilled an inferiority complex into them and had no plan B.

No

No,he and his cronies should learn to keep their gob shut.

Yes!

Sadly, I still believe it was better he left, given what occurred and I am more angry at the way he pulled the wool over the eyes of fans who idolised the guy than I am at the actual texts he (Malky) sent and I still say Moodie was far more culpable!

YES - We had not been in the bottom 3 prior to MM' s sacking and if given funds to strengthen in the January window we would have had a very good chance of staying up.

Malky fucked up in the transfer window, like a kid in a toy shop with an open wallet. His football most likely would have kept us up, but the damage was already done as the trust from Tan was gone!

YES

I think a Yes

Yes.

Yes

No way, people keep on saying we werent in the bottom three when malky was here, but im sure we would have been with the first four games ole had after malky had gone , once your in that bottom three its hard to get out of it who ever the manager

Either way tan created the poisonous atmosphere around the club.

Destroying morale in the dressing.

That and Oles inept tactics = down.

Yes - all day long !

Yes.....................................yes.....................ok thinking about it................yes.

No way, people keep on saying we werent in the bottom three when malky was here, but im sure we would have been with the first four games ole had after malky had gone , once your in that bottom three its hard to get out of it who ever the manager

Would we have got only one point from Sunderland home, Arsenal away, West Ham home........?

100% yes.

No

Yes. Without a shadow of a doubt.

No way, people keep on saying we werent in the bottom three when malky was here, but im sure we would have been with the first four games ole had after malky had gone , once your in that bottom three its hard to get out of it who ever the manager

Would we have got only one point from Sunderland home, Arsenal away, West Ham home........?

Probably, unless we beat Sunderland home

I do think he would've kept us up that season, this season just gone who knows

No, the season we got promoted we had an amazing start however post Christmas we scrapped through and never changed our way of playing hence we came back down.

Dont know !!!!!! The club seemed to be crumbling from the inside