A smart man would sell

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

agree and said it from the start of Arsenals interest: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=142537&hilit=+marshall

Disagree.
As a club we should always try to keep our best players & Marshall is definitely that.
With the amount of points he can win us he'll be worth more than 8mill to us if we get promoted.
At 29 he's just reaching his peak.

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Ive said the same thing in another thread.

Next year he will be a 30 year old keeper in the championship, his value wont increase then. Even if we do go up it will be another year later after again hopefully proving himself in the prem, by then he is 31.

Someone made a good point in another thread, if he played elsewhere would be we happy with Ole signing him for 8m+? I dont think a championship clubs need defensive players like Medel, Caulker, Marshall worth such big value.

As a fan you always want to see us try and keep hold of the top players. Plus keepers hit their prime around that age.

The amount of points he will save us next year and hopefully help in the return to the prem league will be worth a lot more then £8million

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

And a smart fan knows when to quit.You're way off the mark.He may well have another 10yrs+ in him yet.

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

Awaiting your usual childlike response..

No wonder so many have jumped to another forum...

A settled goal keeper makes a hell of a difference to me & he can play for another 5-10 years if he wanted to.

The money getting bandied about is a lot i agree but as already mentioned the price of promotion is so much more.

It's Funny how several on here have issued similar thoughts, but only mine is described as nonsense.

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

Awaiting your usual childlike response..

No wonder so many have jumped to another forum...

Actually he talks sense.

Championship winning squads need a gerat goalkeeper. Which is what we have. Goal keepers generally peaker after 30, and have longer playing careers that outfield players.
He will surely save our arses again and again, and earn us points. With the attacking football Ole wants to play, he needs to be absolutely 110% confident in his defence. Marshall knows our players, and has proven himself to be a top top keeper.

It's Funny how several on here have issued similar thoughts, but only mine is described as nonsense.

That's because I believe it's nonsense. I've given my reasons why I think it's nonsense too. could you answer my questions? Or are you going to troll?

As you keep saying, answer the post, not the poster.

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

Awaiting your usual childlike response..

No wonder so many have jumped to another forum...

Actually he talks sense.

Championship winning squads need a gerat goalkeeper. Which is what we have. Goal keepers generally peaker after 30, and have longer playing careers that outfield players.
He will surely save our arses again and again, and earn us points. With the attacking football Ole wants to play, he needs to be absolutely 110% confident in his defence. Marshall knows our players, and has proven himself to be a top top keeper.

Value wise he peaked.. But Barry is a simpleton who doesn't understand people have different opinions.

If he went to say Southampton for anything around £8m would Southampton sell him for more or close to what they paid?
I'm guessing not..so current value is a premium and the resale value wouldn't be close..

Again Baz... People's Opinions!!!!

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

Awaiting your usual childlike response..

No wonder so many have jumped to another forum...

Actually he talks sense.

Championship winning squads need a gerat goalkeeper. Which is what we have. Goal keepers generally peaker after 30, and have longer playing careers that outfield players.
He will surely save our arses again and again, and earn us points. With the attacking football Ole wants to play, he needs to be absolutely 110% confident in his defence. Marshall knows our players, and has proven himself to be a top top keeper.

Value wise he peaked.. But Barry is a simpleton who doesn't understand people have different opinions.

If he went to say Southampton for anything around £8m would Southampton sell him for more or close to what they paid?
I'm guessing not..so current value is a premium and the resale value wouldn't be close..

Again Baz... People's Opinions!!!!

But to me, the money we get for him is irrelevant if we go up. Personally, at £8m i'de want him to stay, anything £10m+ then I suppose we would have to concede defeat to a PL club. But why let him go now? We will get a bucket load of cash again if we go back up, Ole is building a really exciting team, and Marshall is a very exciting and reliable GK.

I want him to stay at all costs

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

can't we put the pettiness to one side and just talk about the pro's and cons of Marshall staying/going?

But to me, the money we get for him is irrelevant if we go up. Personally, at £8m i'de want him to stay, anything £10m+ then I suppose we would have to concede defeat to a PL club. But why let him go now? We will get a bucket load of cash again if we go back up, Ole is building a really exciting team, and Marshall is a very exciting and reliable GK.

I want him to stay at all costs

Absolutely. As I said, he got us 10 points with his performances the season we went up. I remember the stormer he had at Leicester away... Bellers Snatched a goal and then Marshall kept us in it & we won 1-0.

But to me, the money we get for him is irrelevant if we go up. Personally, at £8m i'de want him to stay, anything £10m+ then I suppose we would have to concede defeat to a PL club. But why let him go now? We will get a bucket load of cash again if we go back up, Ole is building a really exciting team, and Marshall is a very exciting and reliable GK.

I want him to stay at all costs

Absolutely. As I said, he got us 10 points with his performances the season we went up. I remember the stormer he had at Leicester away... Bellers Snatched a goal and then Marshall kept us in it & we won 1-0.

Not to mention the 3 worldies he pulled off in the dying moments of games to save us points. He never switches off, he's always alert and has fantastic ability.

SCOTLAND'S NUMBER 1!

i am prepared to be shot down for this,but should Cardiff receive sizable offer for a 29 yr old with minimal resale value i think they should accept it.
Marsh is great but he peaked last season. his value will never be greater than it currently is,£8m + for a goalkeeper with one years experience in an elite league.

Nonsense. He earned us about 10 points alone the season we went up.

How do you know he peaked last season? How do you know his value will NEVER be greater than it currently is?

Awaiting your usual childlike response..

No wonder so many have jumped to another forum...

Actually he talks sense.

Championship winning squads need a gerat goalkeeper. Which is what we have. Goal keepers generally peaker after 30, and have longer playing careers that outfield players.
He will surely save our arses again and again, and earn us points. With the attacking football Ole wants to play, he needs to be absolutely 110% confident in his defence. Marshall knows our players, and has proven himself to be a top top keeper.

Value wise he peaked.. But Barry is a simpleton who doesn't understand people have different opinions.

If he went to say Southampton for anything around £8m would Southampton sell him for more or close to what they paid?
I'm guessing not..so current value is a premium and the resale value wouldn't be close..

Again Baz... People's Opinions!!!!

But to me, the money we get for him is irrelevant if we go up. Personally, at £8m i'de want him to stay, anything £10m+ then I suppose we would have to concede defeat to a PL club. But why let him go now? We will get a bucket load of cash again if we go back up, Ole is building a really exciting team, and Marshall is a very exciting and reliable GK.

I want him to stay at all costs

Money is irrelevant, four extra million then you will concede defeat?

What's Ramseys current value? Bearing in mind we sold him for £5m. That was bad business.
Selling 29 yr old Marshall for 8+ Knowing his value is unlikely to increase is a good piece of business.


I don't want Marshall to go,far from it. In fact I don't think he will go.
However this is a business and his stock is good so selling him for maximum profit makes good business sense.

That was my "nonsense" point apparently.

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

can't we put the pettiness to one side and just talk about the pro's and cons of Marshall staying/going?

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

You derailed your own thread, I'm afraid. I think you talk nonsense most of the time & I thought you did in this thread too. I then asked you questions related to your post and topic & you come back with calling me a simpleton and ignore those questions related to the topic.

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

You derailed your own thread, I'm afraid. I think you talk nonsense most of the time & I thought you did in this thread too. I then asked you questions related to your post and topic & you come back with calling me a simpleton and ignore those questions related to the topic.

You derailed it the moment you commented..

Questions?
Nope
Question ?
yes.....

And it was answered when I said "Value wise he peaked"
But clearly your to much of a simpleton to grasp that.
Now you say I talk nonsense in all of my threads,then it begs the question "why the f**k do you read it then"?

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

can't we put the pettiness to one side and just talk about the pro's and cons of Marshall staying/going?

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

Yeah but you know how he is, and you bite. Just answer his post and ignore anything you take offence too.
I'm happy for people to say if they think I talk nonsense, I will try my best to back up what I said to prove otherwise.

Or you could just permanently put him on ignore

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

You derailed your own thread, I'm afraid. I think you talk nonsense most of the time & I thought you did in this thread too. I then asked you questions related to your post and topic & you come back with calling me a simpleton and ignore those questions related to the topic.

You follow him around on every near enough every thread. Saying in his opinion he thinks we should sell Marshall for the right price isnt nonsense at all I can see where he is coming from even if my opinion is different to his. You derailed his thread not the other way around.

Have a day off will you!

You derailed it the moment you commented..

no I didn't.

Questions?
Nope
Question ?
yes.....

nope. Definitely 2 questions. I'll break them down for you.

1. How do you know he peaked last season?

2. How do you know his value will never be greater than it currently is?

And it was answered when I said "Value wise he peaked"
But clearly your to much of a simpleton to grasp that.

that's not answering any of the questions I asked.

Now you say I talk nonsense in all of my threads,then it begs the question "why the f**k do you read it then"?

I read every thread and post my opinions on them.

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

can't we put the pettiness to one side and just talk about the pro's and cons of Marshall staying/going?

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

Yeah but you know how he is, and you bite. Just answer his post and ignore anything you take offence too.
I'm happy for people to say if they think I talk nonsense, I will try my best to back up what I said to prove otherwise.

Or you could just permanently put him on ignore

Your spot on in what you say James.
I have tried the ignore and have offered a mutual ignore and stay away as all we do is clash.. But he didn't accept.
That tells me more about him as a person when I actually think about it.

He's back on ignore now anyhow..

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

You derailed your own thread, I'm afraid. I think you talk nonsense most of the time & I thought you did in this thread too. I then asked you questions related to your post and topic & you come back with calling me a simpleton and ignore those questions related to the topic.

You follow him around on every near enough every thread. Saying in his opinion he thinks we should sell Marshall for the right price isnt nonsense at all I can see where he is coming from even if my opinion is different to his. You derailed his thread not the other way around.

Have a day off will you!

Roath was banned for in my opinion doing what Baz has done from day one... Agendas win on the day though.

Demanding people accepted that others have different opinions, then calls me a simpleton for having a different opinion.

Priceless.

can't we put the pettiness to one side and just talk about the pro's and cons of Marshall staying/going?

Sadly all Baz does is pettiness.

This was a good thread but he derailed it.
Maybe it's not so much what he says,just the was he says it..
But he always comments on my posts and they're almost the same stuff.. Nonsense blah blah blah....

Yeah but you know how he is, and you bite. Just answer his post and ignore anything you take offence too.
I'm happy for people to say if they think I talk nonsense, I will try my best to back up what I said to prove otherwise.

Or you could just permanently put him on ignore

Your spot on in what you say James.
I have tried the ignore and have offered a mutual ignore and stay away as all we do is clash.. But he didn't accept.
That tells me more about him as a person when I actually think about it.

He's back on ignore now anyhow..

best way, I only have one person on my ignore list, and it took a lot of BS from him to get on there!!!
I don't generally use the feature, but it is there if we need it. I just wana talk about Cardiff City! That's why (today apart) I just stop posting in a thread that gets derailed and wait for another good topic to talk about!

chuckles strikes again....

chuckles strikes again....

Sadly, some people cant help themselves