Phil Dowd

The pull was outside the box so if he was pulling it back it should be a free kick.

Shocking refereeing. Absolute disgrace.

Shocking f*cking defending more like

He played about 10 sec advantage and gave sunderland a few chances to score

goal scoring oppertunity, plus he pulled him again in the box

goal scoring oppertunity, plus he pulled him again in the box

No he didnt

He played about 10 sec advantage and gave sunderland a few chances to score

I know allows them time to score they fail so give them a bonus chance

He gave a massive advantage and they had a shot on goal. Contact outside the box and minimal contact.

Yeah lets blame the ref for our shit defending

Shocking f*cking defending more like

It might be shocking defending but does that mean the refs allowed to make a terrible mistake like that

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

Penalty.

Dowd allowed advantage, there wasnt any so pulled it back.

Foul committed outside of the box but continued inside.

You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

The penalty You have got to be joking. It was 5 yards outside the box.

Penalty.

Dowd allowed advantage, there wasnt any so pulled it back.

Foul committed outside of the box but continued inside.

How on earth is it a penalty? He fouled him outside the box

Penalty.

Dowd allowed advantage, there wasnt any so pulled it back.

Foul committed outside of the box but continued inside.

The foul started outside. You give the foul from where the offence started.

Its not a penalty at all. Its a free kick as that's where the foul started.

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

The penalty You have got to be joking. It was 5 yards outside the box.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

Penalty.

Dowd allowed advantage, there wasnt any so pulled it back.

Foul committed outside of the box but continued inside.

correct, shit that's a first!

How on earth is it a penalty? He fouled him outside the box

Hes being a self righteous pedantic arsehole again Paul. The foul started outside the box and continued inside. He is right. That means its a free kick because you give it from where the foul started.

Penalty.

Dowd allowed advantage, there wasnt any so pulled it back.

Foul committed outside of the box but continued inside.

How on earth is it a penalty? He fouled him outside the box

If it occurred else where on the pitch and a player was pulling someone's shirt for more than 5 yards the ref would certainly give the foul back where it first occurred. It was never a pen

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

The penalty You have got to be joking. It was 5 yards outside the box.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

The offence started outside the box !!!!

If you start pulling someone back outside the box and it gets waved on, then if it continues inside the box, then its a penalty.

Last edited by Roath_Magic_ on Sun Apr 27, 2014 11:58 am, edited 1 time in total.

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

The penalty You have got to be joking. It was 5 yards outside the box.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

Eh? U give the foul where it was committed.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

No you pull it back to where the foul started. I suggest you look up the rules of the game.

If you start pulling someone back outside the box and it gets waved on, then if it continues inside the box, then its a penalty.

No. You give the foul where it started. For someone who professes a lot about the game you seemingly know feck all.

Correct decision all day long (unfortunately)

It's about time refs played advantage to stop players going to ground - credit to Wickham for staying on his feet. Cala's inept back-pass was the cause.

It's going to be a long afternoon

The penalty You have got to be joking. It was 5 yards outside the box.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

ok carried on in box so what about him playing on to try score or is that not counted? cant have both ways!!

If you start pulling someone back outside the box and it gets waved on, then if it continues inside the box, then its a penalty.

No. You give the foul where it started. For someone who professes a lot about the game you seemingly know feck all.

Well then thats me Graeme Souness, Phil Dowd and Gary Neville who know feck all then.

Penalty.

It continued in the box therefore it is a penalty!!

No you pull it back to where the foul started. I suggest you look up the rules of the game.

Sky and their analysts are wrong then, cause they just said that.

Advantage was played, he allowed the player to carry on, he cant go back.

Basics of football. You either play advantage or you dont.

If you start pulling someone back outside the box and it gets waved on, then if it continues inside the box, then its a penalty.

No. You give the foul where it started. For someone who professes a lot about the game you seemingly know feck all.

Well then thats me Graeme Souness, Phil Dowd and Gary Neville who know feck all then.

Penalty.

Yes, pundits do know nothing.

If you start pulling someone back outside the box and it gets waved on, then if it continues inside the box, then its a penalty.

No. You give the foul where it started. For someone who professes a lot about the game you seemingly know feck all.

Well then thats me Graeme Souness, Phil Dowd and Gary Neville who know feck all then.

Penalty.

Thought you don't listen to pundits

Advantage was played, he allowed the player to carry on, he cant go back.

Basics of football. You either play advantage or you dont.

This.