Ref demoted for disallowing that goal

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/footba ... -goal.html


Even refs get a raw deal sometimes.

This is the reason we have so many referees sticking to the latter of the law instead of using common sense. They don't want to get demoted. It's not the refs fault, it's the FA's fault! Scandalous!

What about Taylor? He got another game straight after the howler at Chelsea ! Plus all of his howlers he had last season !

When referees make a wrong call or are involved in contentious decisions they are quite often demoted for a week .
He made the wrong call in the letters of the law but the right call in the spirit of the game .
The law always wins unfortunately , I thought he had a decent game aswell .

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

the only answer is to allow physios on like rugby, game continues and you wont see so much play acting.

Jones was critiscised by Graham Poll for contravening the laws

A bit f*cking rich from old 2 yellows doesnt = a red

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

Bore off Dickhead

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

you really do watch us in depth. obsessed.

What he should have done is penalised the Norwich player for a foul throw, hed have been ok then, and throw to us, only thing they could debate then would be wether it was or not

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

you really do watch us in depth. obsessed.

It was on MOTD

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

Bore off Dickhead

Great comeback fair play. Outstanding.

exactly and we were on last.

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

My point is that the ref can't just make it up as he goes along. What should have happened is the goal should have stood and Norwich then should have allowed you to walk one in.

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

My point is that the ref can't just make it up as he goes along. What should have happened is the goal should have stood and Norwich then should have allowed you to walk one in.

Maybe the referee could see that there wouldn't be enough time for that & common sense prevailed.

Well done I say.

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

My point is that the ref can't just make it up as he goes along. What should have happened is the goal should have stood and Norwich then should have allowed you to walk one in.

Maybe the referee could see that there wouldn't be enough time for that & common sense prevailed.

Well done I say.

30 seconds get added on for a goal being scored so there would have been plenty of time. Common sense has nothing to do with it, as demonstrated by his demotion this week as you can't pick and chose when to apply the laws of the game to suit.

Anyway, it's a completely moot point.

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

I respectfully disagree. Something you should learn to do.

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

I respectfully disagree. Something you should learn to do.

Wether you disagree with the rules or not is irrelevant. They are the rules.

Ill take Dermots word over yours and a ref renowned for controversy,

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

I respectfully disagree. Something you should learn to do.

Wether you disagree with the rules or not is irrelevant. They are the rules.

Ill take Dermots word over yours and a ref renowned for controversy,

I'll take my view, that of a former top referee, and that of PGMOL who have demoted him.

Oh, and there are no rules in football

Theyve rotated him not demoted him get your facts right.

Theyve rotated him not demoted him get your facts right.

Is that a FACT then?

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

I respectfully disagree. Something you should learn to do.

Wether you disagree with the rules or not is irrelevant. They are the rules.

Ill take Dermots word over yours and a ref renowned for controversy,

NJ73 is a total arse. His opinions make me chuckle. A typical new breed jerk who never went to the vetch field. His only pride is his hatred of Cardiff.

Theyve rotated him not demoted him get your facts right.

Is that a FACT then?

Only as factual as you assuming he's been demoted for that reason.

The ref didnt 'make it up' at all.

Dermot Gallagher cleared the rules up on Sky yday.

He said you dont have to blow the whistle for a throw however after the game has been stopped for an injury the game is to be restarted when the ref blows his whistle.

Yes Jones indicated the Norwich player to throw the ball to Marshall but when he didnt he defused the situation by applying the whistle rule.

No surprise the only ones condemning Jones are that attention seeking clown Poll and the Cardiff obsessed Jack idiot.

I respectfully disagree. Something you should learn to do.

Wether you disagree with the rules or not is irrelevant. They are the rules.

Ill take Dermots word over yours and a ref renowned for controversy,

NJ73 is a total arse. His opinions make me chuckle. A typical new breed jerk who never went to the vetch field. His only pride is his hatred of Cardiff.

Well that shows how much you know of me Gareth. My first game at the Vetch was in 1980 and I've barely missed a home game since new years day 1988 when we drew 2-2 with your lot with Gilligan and Ford scoring right at the deathafter a great overhead kick from Joe Allon and with a goal right from the kick off from Paul Raynor in between your two strikes.

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

My point is that the ref can't just make it up as he goes along. What should have happened is the goal should have stood and Norwich then should have allowed you to walk one in.

this...as long as common sense used..

Theyve rotated him not demoted him get your facts right.

Is that a FACT then?

Only as factual as you assuming he's been demoted for that reason.

I'm basing my assumption on the fact that due to several English refs being needed for Champions League duty next week and therefore not reffing on the weekend, he would have more than likely been needed.

That and the fact he made the cock up in your game of course

And rightly so.

While what Fer did was morally wrong, the ref is clearly shown on the replay from another angle indicting with his arms for the throw to be taken. He can't then change his mind after the event just because Norwich did what they did.

SurelY for the good of the game, you'd prefer the referee did that... Or are you that obsessed?

Good on the ref. common sense prevailed.

My point is that the ref can't just make it up as he goes along. What should have happened is the goal should have stood and Norwich then should have allowed you to walk one in.

this...as long as common sense used..and then you got hughton saying he hadnt agreed.....apalling decision by a dick of a player in my opinion

Read that article properly, HE AS NOT BEEN DEMOTED