Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:53 pm

BluebirdSince55 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.


So if it’s not the managers fault then who decided to play a different way second half and give West Ham the freedom to attack us.
First half Bowen very quiet thanks to Scanlon doing a job on him. The sub for Scanlon should have done the same. It’s the managers job to sort that. BBM to blame for that second half performance.
Take the plaudits for first half but criticism for the second half.


So Tanner should have done the same as Scanlon then?

We were absolutely down to the bare bones, with players running on empty and others playing out of position.

And on top of that, we're up against a squad worth £280 million, with ridiculous quality and options to change the game from the bench, plus a new manager who was always going to demand a reaction.

By the end, we effectively had two full-backs and an attacking winger making up our back four, trying to deal with an England international who can consistently deliver balls into incredibly difficult areas to defend.

I'm not saying mistakes weren't made or that BBM is beyond criticism, but surely the circumstances have to be taken into account?

Some prospective is important otherwise it's just lazy criticism on losing the 3 goal lead.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:59 pm

Nickoblue23 wrote:
BluebirdSince55 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.


So if it’s not the managers fault then who decided to play a different way second half and give West Ham the freedom to attack us.
First half Bowen very quiet thanks to Scanlon doing a job on him. The sub for Scanlon should have done the same. It’s the managers job to sort that. BBM to blame for that second half performance.
Take the plaudits for first half but criticism for the second half.


So Tanner should have done the same as Scanlon then?

We were absolutely down to the bare bones, with players running on empty and others playing out of position.

And on top of that, we're up against a squad worth £280 million, with ridiculous quality and options to change the game from the bench, plus a new manager who was always going to demand a reaction.

By the end, we effectively had two full-backs and an attacking winger making up our back four, trying to deal with an England international who can consistently deliver balls into incredibly difficult areas to defend.

I'm not saying mistakes weren't made or that BBM is beyond criticism, but surely the circumstances have to be taken into account?

Some prospective is important otherwise it's just lazy criticism on losing the 3 goal lead.


Spot on.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 6:07 pm

The reason we dominated the first half is west ham played 4-4-2 so we had the extra man in midfield so Robertson was able to dictate the play , second half west ham went 4-2-3-1 to match our system and we lost the control in midfield , Bowen was then able to get on the ball more and with piro as the target up top to play off it pushed us back 10 yards and we just didnt have the quality on the bench to go toe to toe with them when our starting 11 began to burn out , it is what it is we move on to saturday

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:31 pm

You gotta feel for BBM with the players he had at his disposal last night. The amount of injuries weve had in defence are unreal and we really needed to shut up shop last night. That simply wasn't possible though with who we had available to him and against a side like West Ham.

We soooo need a dog or 2 to call upon to patrol infront of the back 4. And slate this all you want but Wintle would have been handy to call upon last night. Not filling that position (and up front) I do partially blame and hold BBM accountable for. He set his standards too high in the summer window and didn't plan enough behind the scenes - all whilst knowing that we have, arguably, the most unpredicable and volatile owner in UK football.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:37 pm

Nickoblue23 wrote:
BluebirdSince55 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.


So if it’s not the managers fault then who decided to play a different way second half and give West Ham the freedom to attack us.
First half Bowen very quiet thanks to Scanlon doing a job on him. The sub for Scanlon should have done the same. It’s the managers job to sort that. BBM to blame for that second half performance.
Take the plaudits for first half but criticism for the second half.


So Tanner should have done the same as Scanlon then?

We were absolutely down to the bare bones, with players running on empty and others playing out of position.

And on top of that, we're up against a squad worth £280 million, with ridiculous quality and options to change the game from the bench, plus a new manager who was always going to demand a reaction.

By the end, we effectively had two full-backs and an attacking winger making up our back four, trying to deal with an England international who can consistently deliver balls into incredibly difficult areas to defend.

I'm not saying mistakes weren't made or that BBM is beyond criticism, but surely the circumstances have to be taken into account?

Some prospective is important otherwise it's just lazy criticism on losing the 3 goal lead.


Stupid to put Tanner in that position.
Didn’t work v Wolves either.
I don’t care how much West Ham are worth.
We battered them first half.
Yes West Ham changed tactics but so did we for the worse.
Sat back from the kick off and allowed West Ham to play freely with loads of space and no closing down by us. Poor tactics no matter who you are playing.
All that was before we put on subs. If you are going to sit back take off Salech and put a defender on as Salech does nothing anyway. Moylan could have covered up top.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:50 pm

Maloby_Blue wrote:You gotta feel for BBM with the players he had at his disposal last night. The amount of injuries weve had in defence are unreal and we really needed to shut up shop last night. That simply wasn't possible though with who we had available to him and against a side like West Ham.

We soooo need a dog or 2 to call upon to patrol infront of the back 4. And slate this all you want but Wintle would have been handy to call upon last night. Not filling that position (and up front) I do partially blame and hold BBM accountable for. He set his standards too high in the summer window and didn't plan enough behind the scenes - all whilst knowing that we have, arguably, the most unpredicable and volatile owner in UK football.


Agree with that ryan

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 8:41 pm

BluebirdSince55 wrote:
Nickoblue23 wrote:
BluebirdSince55 wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:
Always City wrote:Of course it’s BBM fault he’s the boss and this season he is struggling so he takes the blame,they are his players, open your eyes boy.


Absolute rubbish.

But this is what people do. They just blame the manager because it's the easiest thing to do. It's lazy comments.

He got his tactics spot on, substitutions spot on. We just couldn't see the game out.

And we are not struggling at home, we are one of only five teams unbeaten at home and the others are all top teams - Middlesbrough, Southampton, Swansea and Wolves.


So if it’s not the managers fault then who decided to play a different way second half and give West Ham the freedom to attack us.
First half Bowen very quiet thanks to Scanlon doing a job on him. The sub for Scanlon should have done the same. It’s the managers job to sort that. BBM to blame for that second half performance.
Take the plaudits for first half but criticism for the second half.


So Tanner should have done the same as Scanlon then?

We were absolutely down to the bare bones, with players running on empty and others playing out of position.

And on top of that, we're up against a squad worth £280 million, with ridiculous quality and options to change the game from the bench, plus a new manager who was always going to demand a reaction.

By the end, we effectively had two full-backs and an attacking winger making up our back four, trying to deal with an England international who can consistently deliver balls into incredibly difficult areas to defend.

I'm not saying mistakes weren't made or that BBM is beyond criticism, but surely the circumstances have to be taken into account?

Some prospective is important otherwise it's just lazy criticism on losing the 3 goal lead.


Stupid to put Tanner in that position.
Didn’t work v Wolves either.
I don’t care how much West Ham are worth.
We battered them first half.
Yes West Ham changed tactics but so did we for the worse.
Sat back from the kick off and allowed West Ham to play freely with loads of space and no closing down by us. Poor tactics no matter who you are playing.
All that was before we put on subs. If you are going to sit back take off Salech and put a defender on as Salech does nothing anyway. Moylan could have covered up top.


Read your message back and put yourself in BBM’s position for a moment. What would you have done differently?

You say you would have brought on another defender. Well, he did! But that was because another defender had to go off injured. The only other defensive option available was a 15-year-old lad!

You say Tanner didn’t work. I completely agree, but who else could he have put there?

Bagan could have done a decent job, but moving him out of the middle would have left us even more exposed!

Let’s not forget, we were playing against the most expensive squad in the league, and we were miles off the pace in the first half!

They came out a completely different side in the second half, and given the players we had available, I think we did well in the end to come away with a draw.

They built up so much momentum that it became incredibly difficult to turn the tide, especially when Salech couldn’t hold the ball up and was getting absolutely no protection or support from the officials.

It’s easy to criticise decisions after the game, but when you look at the options BBM actually had available, I’d genuinely like to know what he could have done differently and very doubtful if they would have made that much of a difference.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Thu Nov 05, 2026 8:46 pm

For all those saying that putting Tanner in defence didn't work or is stupid, what would you have done instead given the options left to BBM? Just have nobody on that side? He does a lot of defensive work from the wing & is always tracking back & helping out so he's not totally useless there, again what would you have done differently?

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Fri Nov 06, 2026 12:03 am

Need to see games out - As I have said for years - 2-0 up at Boro Away - 3-0 up WHU at Home of late .
6 Points - End up with 2 :shock:

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:14 am

TopCat CCFC wrote:Need to see games out - As I have said for years - 2-0 up at Boro Away - 3-0 up WHU at Home of late .
6 Points - End up with 2 :shock:



Exactly Tony


And Wrexham beat Boro this week 2-0

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:29 am

Reply:
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Fri Nov 06, 2026 4:52 pm

worcester_ccfc wrote:
Bebbsyboy wrote:
worcester_ccfc wrote:I don't blame the manager at all.

It was just certain players didn't deal with the situation well.


I blame the manager players only play the way the manager tells them


Salech didn't help with hold up play.

Trott's distribution was terrible.

Reason we even had the start we did was the style of play.

Ridiculous if anyone can blame the manager for that second half.


Imagine we had sat back and conceded three then.

Cant win with some people.

Re: I DONT CARE WHO YOU'RE PLAYING / WHEN YOU 3-0 UP YOU WIN

Fri Nov 06, 2026 7:19 pm

Thats why bbm plays high up the pitch , he knows our defence isn't good enough so sets up to attack and keep sides in there own half .
Trouble is like last season we struggle against teams who counter attack , we miss wintle which I think bielek has been brought in but availability hasn't been able to address his plans