A forum for all things Cardiff City
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:35 pm
Very poor again tonight I really watched him hard tonight yes he got dragged down a few times and should have gained a few free kicks ,
but he is just not cutting it ,look at moylan showing him how it's done he is not winning any ariel battles I know we have no choice but he is just not on it slow and ponderious.
We really need that other striker come january.
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:46 pm
His hold up play was terrible and a main reason why we kept giving the ball back to them.
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:49 pm
The game is about levels, and their centre-halves were a level above him
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:50 pm
Need a new no9 sharpish
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:57 pm
wez1927 wrote:Need a new no9 sharpish
Wes we already have him Jack Moylan should play there, centre forward. Rubin etc in behind .
When BBM put Moylan out wide it killed all our threat
Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:58 pm
At the moment he couldn’t trap a bag of cement.
Needs to work on his hold up play big time.
Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:01 pm
Salech was getting no joy. Leaving him on and then moving Moylan out wide was a massive mistake.
Salech should have gone off with Moylan going up front.
Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:04 pm
A target man. Who can't hold the ball up or win 50/50 headers outside there box and heat bullied then waves his hands like he's in a f*cking boyzone concert half the time. Hardly moves about and stands on the center half . Moyland drops in space so there's a bit difference in types of players. We didn't crosses the ball once I dont think to salech where he's better at heading it. A pointless player the way we are playing right now id prefer moylan there.
Last edited by Bluebird1977 on Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:05 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:05 pm
Their centre-halves are valued at £30 million, they mullured him..... They were playing Haaland last season
I don't think he is suited to BBM ball. He looked a different player with wingers (old school) 2 seasons ago
Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:03 am
llan bluebird wrote:Their centre-halves are valued at £30 million, they mullured him..... They were playing Haaland last season
I don't think he is suited to BBM ball. He looked a different player with wingers (old school) 2 seasons ago
Said this for ages what summed it up was the fact near halftime he touched ball 4 times (least of all on pitch) that wasn’t because he couldn't hold ball up its because he never got the effin thing... him uptop on his own does not and as not worked and won't work next game either ... you either play with wingers who put in decent crosses or you play with a false 9 that doesn’t rely on crosses to score .... Willock and Tanner do not see salech when out wide they prefer to look for inside pass most of times..... yes people say we put in loads crosses but who too not salech? Our successful cross ratio is poor most games which means they're going nowhere well not to any city player.... their two goals were balls iver top & down middle to a player...... did that happen to salech last night? "NO" so holding ball up facing his own goal with 2 defenders on him is not conducive to holding ball up with team mates 20yrds or more awa from you. He as shown hes capbable of scoring good goals if given proper service something that is sorely lacking this season. People suggest moylan uptop with player behind him wouldn't it be a novelty to do tthat with Salech?
Thu Nov 05, 2026 7:31 am
Needs to work on his mobility off the ball running ...He's not suited to our pass and move style. Moylan
up there is the better option(he's a waste wide left) We need a Kellyman type as an alternative, if he's out
there last night we would probably win the game.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:29 am
I said last week that Moylan needs to be our striker and rotate him with Salech
Then rotate Rubin and Ashford in the 10 role
BBMs subs are baffling at times and I find it strange that he's left Ashford out after how much he's improved in the 10 role
I'm a huge fan of Rubin but to throw him in after a lengthy time out and drop Ashford sends the wrong message
It's telling certain players in the squad that no matter how well you play you will not start games if certain other players are available
Thu Nov 05, 2026 9:42 am
llan bluebird wrote:Their centre-halves are valued at £30 million, they mullured him..... They were playing Haaland last season
I don't think he is suited to BBM ball. He looked a different player with wingers (old school) 2 seasons ago
And how did they do against Haaland?
Oh, hang on! They’re now playing in the Championship!
On a more serious note, I think we need to separate the two halves of last night’s game, and in the second half, West Ham showed what they could be about this season! We were lucky to survive in the end and I see ‘
The Spiv’ giving them the boost they need to challenge at the top of the table
As for Salech? I don’t think anyone had much negative to say about him in the first half, where he more than players his part, and my group actually discussed how he ‘
finally seemed to be getting his act back together’ as a target man, allowing Jack Moylan to ‘
do his thing’!
Like others, he (Salech) faded in the second half, as we allowed ourselves to panic a little and be overrun, but we took a point against a very good side, and we move on to an important game versus Burnley this Saturday!
Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:00 am
Salech not great but he's hardly to blame for us leaking three more goals because he didn't hold the ball up very well!
Our weak, depleted defence is the problem who are not being given the protection in midfield that they need.
One clean sheet in 14 games means we'll always be struggling.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:12 am
davids wrote:Salech not great but he's hardly to blame for us leaking three more goals because he didn't hold the ball up very well!
Our weak, depleted defence is the problem who are not being given the protection in midfield that they need.
One clean sheet in 14 games means we'll always be struggling.
He does have to take some responsibility for it.
His poor hold up play and not being strong enough was a key reason why we kept giving the ball back to them, which resulted in them getting back into the game.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:20 am
worcester_ccfc wrote:davids wrote:Salech not great but he's hardly to blame for us leaking three more goals because he didn't hold the ball up very well!
Our weak, depleted defence is the problem who are not being given the protection in midfield that they need.
One clean sheet in 14 games means we'll always be struggling.
He does have to take some responsibility for it.
His poor hold up play and not being strong enough was a key reason why we kept giving the ball back to them, which resulted in them getting back into the game.
Yes he does but so does every other player in the second half.
We couldn't seem to string two passes together.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 10:24 am
davids wrote:worcester_ccfc wrote:davids wrote:Salech not great but he's hardly to blame for us leaking three more goals because he didn't hold the ball up very well!
Our weak, depleted defence is the problem who are not being given the protection in midfield that they need.
One clean sheet in 14 games means we'll always be struggling.
He does have to take some responsibility for it.
His poor hold up play and not being strong enough was a key reason why we kept giving the ball back to them, which resulted in them getting back into the game.
Yes he does but so does every other player in the second half.
We couldn't seem to string two passes together.
I can remember a passing sequence of two or more from us in the second half on several occasions actually.
But do not underestimate the impact that the poor hold up play had. Others have been quick to go for the manager which is ridiculous, I don't put any blame on him but I do put a blame on Salech.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:30 pm
So we score 3 and people want to blame Salech again. I'm on the fence about who the club scapegoat is Salech or Tanner.... BBM should have brought Bacuna back so we could all agree on who the worst player at the club was
Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:32 pm
Starvinmarvin wrote:So we score 3 and people want to blame Salech again. I'm on the fence about who the club scapegoat is Salech or Tanner.... BBM should have brought Bacuna back so we could all agree on who the worst player at the club was
To be fair his hold up play was poor. He wasn't strong enough.
I get it's a difficult balancing act for him because whenever he's strong in those situations, a foul is given against him.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 2:57 pm
Starvinmarvin wrote:So we score 3 and people want to blame Salech again. I'm on the fence about who the club scapegoat is Salech or Tanner.... BBM should have brought Bacuna back so we could all agree on who the worst player at the club was
They get to take turns at that, makes it much fairer don't you know.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:12 pm
Sven wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Their centre-halves are valued at £30 million, they mullured him..... They were playing Haaland last season
I don't think he is suited to BBM ball. He looked a different player with wingers (old school) 2 seasons ago
And how did they do against Haaland?
Oh, hang on! They’re now playing in the Championship!
On a more serious note, I think we need to separate the two halves of last night’s game, and in the second half, West Ham showed what they could be about this season! We were lucky to survive in the end and I see ‘
The Spiv’ giving them the boost they need to challenge at the top of the table
As for Salech? I don’t think anyone had much negative to say about him in the first half, where he more than players his part, and my group actually discussed how he ‘
finally seemed to be getting his act back together’ as a target man, allowing Jack Moylan to ‘
do his thing’!
Like others, he (Salech) faded in the second half, as we allowed ourselves to panic a little and be overrun, but we took a point against a very good side, and we move on to an important game versus Burnley this Saturday!

We had to play a very weak team in the 2nd half; losing NG, Scanlon, Rubin, Willock, Joel, and Ashford were OK, but Kpacio and Turnbull were a downgrade, and Tanner had to play in defence. That's mostly why we struggle, plus their subs were £1millions players and better than the starters.
Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:26 pm
I think hes been terrible since he had that bump on the head if im honest. I agree that Moylan should be our number 9 until [ or if ] Tan dips in his pocket and buys a quality striker !!
Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:39 pm
Ronaldo is, available
Fri Nov 06, 2026 2:40 am
Bluebina wrote:Sven wrote:llan bluebird wrote:Their centre-halves are valued at £30 million, they mullured him..... They were playing Haaland last season
I don't think he is suited to BBM ball. He looked a different player with wingers (old school) 2 seasons ago
And how did they do against Haaland?
Oh, hang on! They’re now playing in the Championship!
On a more serious note, I think we need to separate the two halves of last night’s game, and in the second half, West Ham showed what they could be about this season! We were lucky to survive in the end and I see ‘
The Spiv’ giving them the boost they need to challenge at the top of the table
As for Salech? I don’t think anyone had much negative to say about him in the first half, where he more than players his part, and my group actually discussed how he ‘
finally seemed to be getting his act back together’ as a target man, allowing Jack Moylan to ‘
do his thing’!
Like others, he (Salech) faded in the second half, as we allowed ourselves to panic a little and be overrun, but we took a point against a very good side, and we move on to an important game versus Burnley this Saturday!

We had to play a very weak team in the 2nd half; losing NG, Scanlon, Rubin, Willock, Joel, and Ashford were OK, but Kpacio and Turnbull were a downgrade, and Tanner had to play in defence. That's mostly why we struggle, plus their subs were £1millions players and better than the starters.
I don’t disagree. My point was someone comparing WHam playing against Haaland when they got relegated as a result
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group.
phpBB Mobile / SEO by Artodia.