Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:14 pm

3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:17 pm

Or players had run their race and need to be protected from injury. Subs are not always tactical.

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:23 pm

I could understand NG going off as he went down injured, but taking Scanlon off who was having a good game made no sense, especially as Tanner had to go left back again.

Also, Moylan had a hat-trick with another fantastic display and he moves him out to the left where he couldn't get as involved! WHY??????? :banghead:

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:24 pm

Ng having a knock didn't help.

Don't know if the medical team will let Scanlon play 90 minutes yet and would imagine the original plan was for Kpakio to come on as LB in the second half - Ng knock scuppered that.

Thankfully we shouldn't have to see Tanner at LB again with Osho back on Saturday.

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:34 pm

Players like rubin scanlon etc haven't played a lot of minutes and flogging them in to the ground would risk losing them to more injuries , bbm is doing the best he can with an absolute thread bare squad

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:49 pm

Tailgunner wrote:3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs



That result had nothing to do with the changes made, and for me, every decision BBM made was the right one.

The goals were coming ages before the subs and we just couldn't match their reaction and instead we looked to hang on with tired bodies and minds.

Ruban, Scanlon and NG were all forced changes.

The threadbare squad isn't just limiting the options BBM has off the bench; it's also taking its toll on players like Tanner, Robertson and Bagan, who are now running on empty.

We simply ran out of legs in the second half and couldn't maintain the intensity of our first-half press.

Despite that, the players showed fantastic heart and commitment. If we're being honest, as soon as our energy levels dropped, the quality of players like Bowen really started to shine through, and ultimately, we were punished.

You can't fault the effort or the decisions made. We're simply being stretched to the limit by a lack of squad depth and injuries.

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:51 pm

Nickoblue23 wrote:
Tailgunner wrote:3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs



That result had nothing to do with the changes made, and for me, every decision BBM made was the right one.

The goals were coming ages before the subs and we just couldn't match their reaction and instead we looked to hang on with tired bodies and minds.

Ruban, Scalon and NG were all forced changes.

The threadbare squad isn't just limiting the options BBM has off the bench; it's also taking its toll on players like Tanner, Robertson and Bagan, who are now running on empty.

We simply ran out of legs in the second half and couldn't maintain the intensity of our first-half press.

Despite that, the players showed fantastic heart and commitment. If we're being honest, as soon as our energy levels dropped, the quality of players like Bowen really started to shine through, and ultimately, we were punished.

You can't fault the effort or the decisions made. We're simply being stretched to the limit by a lack of squad depth and injuries.


:thumbup: spot on.
We need 5 players in over the winter window

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:21 pm

llan bluebird wrote:
Nickoblue23 wrote:
Tailgunner wrote:3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs



That result had nothing to do with the changes made, and for me, every decision BBM made was the right one.

The goals were coming ages before the subs and we just couldn't match their reaction and instead we looked to hang on with tired bodies and minds.

Ruban, Scalon and NG were all forced changes.

The threadbare squad isn't just limiting the options BBM has off the bench; it's also taking its toll on players like Tanner, Robertson and Bagan, who are now running on empty.

We simply ran out of legs in the second half and couldn't maintain the intensity of our first-half press.

Despite that, the players showed fantastic heart and commitment. If we're being honest, as soon as our energy levels dropped, the quality of players like Bowen really started to shine through, and ultimately, we were punished.

You can't fault the effort or the decisions made. We're simply being stretched to the limit by a lack of squad depth and injuries.


:thumbup: spot on.
We need 5 players in over the winter window


We needed them before the season started and had four months to sort it out.

Absolutely no chance we'll sign that many in January.

In three full transfer windows so far since BBM arrived we've signed a total of seven players including a reserve goalie who never plays and Scanlon who's signed on loan twice.

I would guess we might see one loan come in if we're lucky and it's likely to be an inexperienced youngster.

Re: FFS Subs

Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:32 pm

The only one I didn’t get was Ashford for Willock..
I thought Willock was having a great game.. Ashford seems to have his arrogant hat on again .. no running at players, no chasing back..
Ng and Rubin both had to be replaced..

Re: FFS Subs

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:27 am

Scanlon had a pull too apparently. The only tactical sub was Ashford for Willock which is usually a pretty safe bet but didn't work out great today

Re: FFS Subs

Thu Nov 05, 2026 4:28 am

Nickoblue23 wrote:
Tailgunner wrote:3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs



That result had nothing to do with the changes made, and for me, every decision BBM made was the right one.

The goals were coming ages before the subs and we just couldn't match their reaction and instead we looked to hang on with tired bodies and minds.

Ruban, Scanlon and NG were all forced changes.

The threadbare squad isn't just limiting the options BBM has off the bench; it's also taking its toll on players like Tanner, Robertson and Bagan, who are now running on empty.

We simply ran out of legs in the second half and couldn't maintain the intensity of our first-half press.

Despite that, the players showed fantastic heart and commitment. If we're being honest, as soon as our energy levels dropped, the quality of players like Bowen really started to shine through, and ultimately, we were punished.

You can't fault the effort or the decisions made. We're simply being stretched to the limit by a lack of squad depth and injuries.




The subs didn’t change anything but what did change was parkers tactics 2nd half of dropping bowen deeper and he controlled game from there 3 goals 3 passes ftom bowen! What changes did bbm do to stop this? "NOTHING" and that is a frequent occurrence no response to an oppositions coaches tactical change instead of closing bowen down we gave him acres of space which everyone knows is suicidal given his talents... and other thing is trott? For some reason hes hesitating a lot coming out happed in previous games and last night several times it happened and the 3rd goal he held out hands waiting for ball to arrive which of course it didn’t it was a simple go get ball before it reached the static defenders ... all in all another game where we gifted opposition the goals rather than them fight for them....

Re: FFS Subs

Thu Nov 05, 2026 5:42 pm

pembroke allan wrote:
Nickoblue23 wrote:
Tailgunner wrote:3-0 up brings on Ashford WTF why ?
Then takes off Scanlon
WTF as well
Lucky to draw stupid subs



That result had nothing to do with the changes made, and for me, every decision BBM made was the right one.

The goals were coming ages before the subs and we just couldn't match their reaction and instead we looked to hang on with tired bodies and minds.

Ruban, Scanlon and NG were all forced changes.

The threadbare squad isn't just limiting the options BBM has off the bench; it's also taking its toll on players like Tanner, Robertson and Bagan, who are now running on empty.

We simply ran out of legs in the second half and couldn't maintain the intensity of our first-half press.

Despite that, the players showed fantastic heart and commitment. If we're being honest, as soon as our energy levels dropped, the quality of players like Bowen really started to shine through, and ultimately, we were punished.

You can't fault the effort or the decisions made. We're simply being stretched to the limit by a lack of squad depth and injuries.




The subs didn’t change anything but what did change was parkers tactics 2nd half of dropping bowen deeper and he controlled game from there 3 goals 3 passes ftom bowen! What changes did bbm do to stop this? "NOTHING" and that is a frequent occurrence no response to an oppositions coaches tactical change instead of closing bowen down we gave him acres of space which everyone knows is suicidal given his talents... and other thing is trott? For some reason hes hesitating a lot coming out happed in previous games and last night several times it happened and the 3rd goal he held out hands waiting for ball to arrive which of course it didn’t it was a simple go get ball before it reached the static defenders ... all in all another game where we gifted opposition the goals rather than them fight for them....


Totally agree with you that Parker changing tactics had a huge impact on the game.

He also had the luxury of bringing on a £10m player who's scored goals in the Premier League and is a real handful.

Bowen was outstanding, but let's not forget he's an England international who wouldn't look out of place at Villa or Man United. It's ridiculous to have that level of guaranteed quality in the Championship!

Yes, BBM could have moved Bagan out of centre-back to man-mark him, but we only had two recognised defenders on the pitch when they scored their third. That could just as easily have created an even bigger hole elsewhere, and we might have ended up losing the game. Tanner was the one up against Bowen in the end.

For me, we made some fundamental individual errors that contributed to the goals, and I don't think you can simply put those down to the manager.

Scanlon got dragged out of position for the first, Fish lost his runner for the flick-on, and I think Trott has to come and punch the third. The ball ends up around foot height inside his six-yard box and is actually curling towards him.

That said, they created other chances where we defended brilliantly, throwing bodies in the way and making some fantastic last-ditch challenges. The effort and commitment were certainly there.

It's frustrating, of course, but sometimes you have to give the opposition credit too. Parker made changes that worked, and they had the quality to take advantage.

Take the point, move on!