Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Robertson

Wed Nov 04, 2026 10:47 pm

He is excellent in possession, but it's clear if we want to keep playing him in a deeper role, he needs a protector alongside him who can track runners and snuff out danger.

All 3 goals were partially Robertson's fault.

The first goal, he didn't track the runner, allowing the ball to go over him.

The second goal was Fish's fault for allowing their player to run past him and then Robertson was exposed with two players. Robertson allowed their first player to flick the ball on for his teammate to run through to score. Could Robertson have stepped out to play him offside? Could he have dropped back a couple of yards to anticipate the flick on and be in the correct position to stop him running through? I think a player who knows the position e.g. Gunnarsson wouldn't have got caught out like that.

Their third goal was what annoyed me the most, it was a combination of Robertson and Trott not dealing with the cross. Robertson left it thinking Trott would come out. Trott hesitated thinking Robertson would deal with it, but Robertson left it and then it was too late. If one of Robertson or Trott did their jobs, the goal would have been stopped, but because they both failed to deal with it, we conceded yet another soft goal.

Trott really needed to come racing out to punch the ball clear for their third goal, whether Robertson dealed with it or not. I was really disappointed with Trott, he didn't want to take charge and it cost us. No decisiveness, no courage, no bravery, he just stood on his line hoping Robertson would deal with it. A good keeper would have come sprinting out to punch it clear, wiping everything away.

Going back to Robertson, he's clearly one of our best players and a huge reason why we play this way with our possession based style. On the ball, he's great, but off the ball, we can't rely on just him alone to protect our defence. That's not his strength. We need someone alongside him who knows the position and actually enjoys defending, by running the hard yards, tracking runners and taking the correct positions to pick up the loose balls and anticipate danger.

Re: Robertson

Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:05 pm

Trott was at fault for the 3rd goal. In that situation it should always be the keeper coming for it and screaming it’s his ball. But then Trott saved a few certain goals with his saves.

Hey ho and we go again Saturday.

Re: Robertson

Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:06 pm

Yeah, first half he was really good because he was able to dictate play but without doubt struggled during the second half with covering their runs.

I can't see him being replaced as the six, even if someone in that position came in during January, because it's clearly the manager's project for the season. It could take him a lot of games yet to master it - had the odd game where he's done everything right but is still learning.

As you say, he's a very talented player on the ball but his off the ball stuff needs work.

Re: Robertson

Wed Nov 04, 2026 11:09 pm

I think Parker did a great job in changing the second half. There were too many runners for us to deal with plus we were slow and seeing the danger but our high line invites it

Its how we play

Re: Robertson

Thu Nov 05, 2026 12:30 am

worcester_ccfc wrote:Yeah, first half he was really good because he was able to dictate play but without doubt struggled during the second half with covering their runs.

I can't see him being replaced as the six, even if someone in that position came in during January, because it's clearly the manager's project for the season. It could take him a lot of games yet to master it - had the odd game where he's done everything right but is still learning.

As you say, he's a very talented player on the ball but his off the ball stuff needs work.


It's the same thing as when Rubin has dropped in at 6 a couple of times, great at spreading the ball around but you need a guy there that can do all the defensive dirty work. I'd love to see Robertson a bit further up again. This team would be right up there with a Gunnarson type in it

Re: Robertson

Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:35 pm

Tonteg Bluebird wrote:He is excellent in possession, but it's clear if we want to keep playing him in a deeper role, he needs a protector alongside him who can track runners and snuff out danger.

All 3 goals were partially Robertson's fault.

The first goal, he didn't track the runner, allowing the ball to go over him.

The second goal was Fish's fault for allowing their player to run past him and then Robertson was exposed with two players. Robertson allowed their first player to flick the ball on for his teammate to run through to score. Could Robertson have stepped out to play him offside? Could he have dropped back a couple of yards to anticipate the flick on and be in the correct position to stop him running through? I think a player who knows the position e.g. Gunnarsson wouldn't have got caught out like that.

Their third goal was what annoyed me the most, it was a combination of Robertson and Trott not dealing with the cross. Robertson left it thinking Trott would come out. Trott hesitated thinking Robertson would deal with it, but Robertson left it and then it was too late. If one of Robertson or Trott did their jobs, the goal would have been stopped, but because they both failed to deal with it, we conceded yet another soft goal.

Trott really needed to come racing out to punch the ball clear for their third goal, whether Robertson dealed with it or not. I was really disappointed with Trott, he didn't want to take charge and it cost us. No decisiveness, no courage, no bravery, he just stood on his line hoping Robertson would deal with it. A good keeper would have come sprinting out to punch it clear, wiping everything away.

Going back to Robertson, he's clearly one of our best players and a huge reason why we play this way with our possession based style. On the ball, he's great, but off the ball, we can't rely on just him alone to protect our defence. That's not his strength. We need someone alongside him who knows the position and actually enjoys defending, by running the hard yards, tracking runners and taking the correct positions to pick up the loose balls and anticipate danger.


Maybe Joel or Bielik as support for some games; or possibly sign a player with that profile; you make some good points.

Re: Robertson

Thu Nov 05, 2026 3:40 pm

Bielik 6 Robertson 8 rubin 10 moylan false 9 tanner scanlon on the wings , id like to see this at some stage