McPhail

Should be playing to give us stability. Has been playing for reserves lately so must be fit.

NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO.

Brings nothing to the team that is positive.

Too one sided (probably the most one footed player in the game).

Only side or backwards passes.
So nothing is created or forward movement from him.

Too slow in pace and cannot score goals. Cannot shoot or head the ball.
Cannot tackle (look at free kicks he concedes, and bookings for bad and late tackles (usually as he tries to spin around to tackle with his only good leg, so getting caught in awkward angles and so late tackles).

In summary therfore. No place in team as he is shit.

I agree Mcphail should be playing some part,he has experience and gels the front and backline,anyone who says he isn't good enough know nothing about the game.

I agree Mcphail should be playing some part,he has experience and gels the front and backline,anyone who says he isn't good enough know nothing about the game.

I'm another one who knows nothing about the game then, as McPhail isn't good enough to get in our midfield now!

I've always liked McPhail as a player (except against the Jacks ), but his best days are way behind him and I'd be shocked if he gets another contract with us after this season!

I think he could be used in away games. Malky always seems to want Whitts playing deep in front of the back four, so maybe if we put Macca there to distibute the ball Whitts could player further up the field

I think he could be used in away games. Malky always seems to want Whitts playing deep in front of the back four, so maybe if we put Macca there to distibute the ball Whitts could player further up the field

So who would you drop for him, if all our midfield options were fit then?

I think he could be used in away games. Malky always seems to want Whitts playing deep in front of the back four, so maybe if we put Macca there to distibute the ball Whitts could player further up the field

Who's place would he take in the team?

He can only last 10 mins of a game.

Has he played 90mins (in total ) in 2 years?

Sicknote of a player. We already have Mutch, so McPhail is surplus to requirements for that as well.

he may only pass the backwards or sideways but at 2-0 up i think thats the sort of player we need, a player who keeps hold of the ball if he had played last night we would not have lost

he may only pass the backwards or sideways but at 2-0 up i think thats the sort of player we need, a player who keeps hold of the ball if he had played last night we would not have lost

he may only pass the backwards or sideways but at 2-0 up i think thats the sort of player we need, a player who keeps hold of the ball if he had played last night we would not have lost

Can he catch crosses and head the ball away from our 6 yard box?

he would have protected the back four

he may only pass the backwards or sideways but at 2-0 up i think thats the sort of player we need, a player who keeps hold of the ball if he had played last night we would not have lost

Can he catch crosses and head the ball away from our 6 yard box?

he may only pass the backwards or sideways but at 2-0 up i think thats the sort of player we need, a player who keeps hold of the ball if he had played last night we would not have lost

I honestly don't recall him making a difference when we've been up against it. He's played well when we've been on top but he's had some shockers when he's needed to graft in midfield.