Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:00 pm

Why police only ? my kids & wife are just as important as they are. :old:

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:01 pm

No way, ive dealt with the police and some of them are not worth shit, to be above everyone else in this country.. No way... They should have the same laws and rules as everyone else.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:30 pm

I'd like to see people like rapist, pedo's and serial killers get sent to the front line to clear IED's and mines for our boys instead, or instead of using animals for testing, use them.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:31 pm

I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:32 pm

Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:38 pm

OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 5:48 pm

Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.


Personally, I don't see what is achieved by that.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:07 pm

Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.



so if two guys get into a fight and one falls over and hits his head and dies..... the guy who hits him deserves the death penalty? :?

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:09 pm

OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.


Personally, I don't see what is achieved by that.

justice

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:10 pm

no, thats not justice at all

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:12 pm

As long as the UK remains a member state of the European Union capital punishment cannot be reintroduced as it the contrary to the Eurpoean Convention On Human Rights.


Personally I think it's a good thing that we can't bring it back because I will never support the state taking a human life, however when someone is found guilty of murder they should be put away for life. And I mean life.


:ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:12 pm

paulh_85 wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.



so if two guys get into a fight and one falls over and hits his head and dies..... the guy who hits him deserves the death penalty? :?

The legal definition of murder is that if you intend to kill someone or intend to cause them grievous bodily harm, and they die as a result, then that is murder.

The kind of scenario you rae talking about would probably fall into the legal definition of manslaughter.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:13 pm

paulh_85 wrote:no, thats not justice at all

it's all about opinions - yours differs fom mine.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 6:40 pm

He will rot in Jail for most of his life and the screws will run a train on his ass on a daily basis.

That you can be sure of.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 7:43 pm

blue nile wrote:undecieded myself :?:

Naaaah! Only child killers should qualify for the hangmans noose! And terrorists who commit mass atrocities on british soil.

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 7:56 pm

Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.


Personally, I don't see what is achieved by that.

justice


Quote from Desmond Tutu.

"Taking a life when a life has been taken is revenge, not justice".

Re: Death Penalty for Police Killers ( Whats your Opinion)

Wed Sep 19, 2012 10:39 pm

OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:
OhhhGa wrote:
Die Walkure wrote:I strongly support the re-introduction of capital punishment.


For what reasons?

Philosophically, I believe that if someone has murdered someone (i.e. intended to kill them or cause them GBH and they die as a result), then the appropriate punishment is that they then forfeit their life.


Personally, I don't see what is achieved by that.

justice


Quote from Desmond Tutu.

"Taking a life when a life has been taken is revenge, not justice".

As I said, it's all about opinions - for me, capital punishment is justice for murder - for you and Desmond, it is not.