Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

We wanted to keep them... 3 of the worst!!

Tue Sep 11, 2012 8:34 pm

Many city fans wanted to keep Gunter, Matthews and Blake!

In my opinion they were all shite tonight!! I know the whole team was but these three stood out as extra shite for me, and made me wonder...

In hindsight was it best to get rid when we did for some cash?
Would they be different players if they had stayed?
Blake aside, would Gunter/Matthews be in our side now?

Re: We wanted to keep them... 3 of the worst!!

Tue Sep 11, 2012 9:07 pm

gunters a very good championship level player,matthews wouldnt get in our current side in my opinion

Re: We wanted to keep them... 3 of the worst!!

Tue Sep 11, 2012 9:20 pm

People just look at it with their anti dj goggles but the man was 100% correct on all 3.

Matthews in particular was and is never the player City fans make out.

And 4.5m for Ramsey isnt looking the outrageous steal people make out now eithet

Re: We wanted to keep them... 3 of the worst!!

Tue Sep 11, 2012 9:44 pm

I've always liked Gunter to be fair but I'd agree he's only championship, but would he be better if he stayed and played and hadn't warmed the bench at Spurs?? I think he lost confidence and went backwards going there!

I didn't want to include Ramsey, we didnt sell this Ramsey! He's nothing like the player he was before his injury, still a prem player tho which he proved when he shone on loan! Will be a shame if he never gets back his old form and confidence!!

And Matthews was never played enough to know how good he was, but again would he have grown had he stayed?? Maybe!

What if's.... It's what makes sport so enjoyable!!

:ayatollah:

Re: We wanted to keep them... 3 of the worst!!

Tue Sep 11, 2012 9:58 pm

None of them good enough irrespective of tonight's game.

Matthews maybe for the U21 team.