Manics or Phonics?

Who do you prefer, Manic Street Preachers or Stereophonics?



Personally I prefer MSP, but the Phonics are also amazing

to be brutally honest both are both pub bands at best !

Manics

to be brutally honest both are both pub bands at best !

Every man to his own

Would rather The Alarm but in answer to the question it would be The Manics

Manics

Phonics everytime

MPS make we want suicide and SPs remind me of rugby international day plums.

MPS make we want suicide and SPs remind me of rugby international day plums.

Is that a vote for Manic Preachers Street then?

MPS make we want suicide and SPs remind me of rugby international day plums.

Is that a vote for Manic Preachers Street then?

Prob lean towards Phonics

PHONICS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Manics

phonics over a certain period but during their full careers the manics ..... why i say that is because i think word gets around is the greatest welsh album of all-time!

50/50 here

Manics all day long. Not fussed on that kelly jones, seems like an arrogant tosser.

Manics

not a big lover of either band but would pick manics if had to choose.

Manics. Always found Sterophonics very over rated.

Out of the two I prefer the manics,but if your talking about the best welsh bands its Budgie for me.Cardiff City wounld'nt go far wrong comming out of the tunnel to Breadfan

Out of the two I prefer the manics,but if your talking about the best welsh bands its Budgie for me.Cardiff City wounld'nt go far wrong comming out of the tunnel to Breadfan

I,ll drink to that

Out of the two I prefer the manics,but if your talking about the best welsh bands its Budgie for me.Cardiff City wounld'nt go far wrong comming out of the tunnel to Breadfan

I,ll drink to that

They Can Run out to Breadan, Panzer Division Deystroyed as goal celebration music, CrIme Against the World when the ref cocks up.

We Are All living in Cloud Cuckoo Land could be the club Anthem.


Oh O.P Manics best of the two

Phonics are shit and the singer supports leeds so is automatically a c**t.

Manics Easy. Legends.

The Super Furry Animals best Welsh band for me. But out of the two mentioned. The Manics.

MSP by a long way. It's ridiculous even comparing the two

Manics by a country mile. More angst, more meaning, more passion.

Both shit.

Always preffered Phonics however, Design for life is the Best track to ever be released by a welsh band IMO .