Smith or Maynard

Given the choice who would you prefer?

For me it has to be Maynard - 84 goals in 210 appearances against Smith's 102 in 514 apperances. Plus Maynard is still only 25 whilst Smith is now 32 so commercially makes more sense

Maynard but not for £4,000,000.

im not a fan of smith to be honest...

But Smith is also a winger, he can play striker but plays mostly as a winger scores less goals.

Maynard 100%. If he could reproduce the form of 2 years ago. I think we should take a gamble on him, depending on the price of course.

Maynard scores goals and has pace something we havent got..Helguson is good in the air, but we need paceman

But Smith is also a winger, he can play striker but plays mostly as a winger scores less goals.

A winger with no pace.....we got them already...Conway, Cowie. Last season we had Lawrence too. I like my wingers with pace....such as Bellamy. So the answer to the question....MAYNARD

Different positions

Different positions

Sure, Smith is a winger/striker. Just that we have been linked to both and certainly won't be signing both so given the choice, which would you prefer? I feel we need a Maynard more than a Smith

Different positions

Sure, Smith is a winger/striker. Just that we have been linked to both and certainly won't be signing both so given the choice, which would you prefer? I feel we need a Maynard more than a Smith

I agree with need Maynard more than Smith but I dont think its a choice between them two

Maynards not as good as he was at Brizzle.

I'd take Smith, seems to have a better attitude.