Tom Heaton or David Marshall

with marshall in goals in the last couple of games he hasnt had many clean sheets,isit time for heaton to have a go?

Mind you, we had a decent defence tonight. Gerrard made a difference imo. Just change Hudson now

I don't really mind either. But Marshall's performance at Wembley will haunt me for the rest of my life

Heaton for me!

Mind you, we had a decent defence tonight. Gerrard made a difference imo. Just change Hudson now

Why are people so quick to slate this guy?!

I think a clean sheet against an attack consisting of Charlie Austin and Jay Rodriguez tells its own story!

Heaton and Marshall are both good solid keepers, I don't mind who.

Mind you, we had a decent defence tonight. Gerrard made a difference imo. Just change Hudson now

Why are people so quick to slate this guy?!

I think a clean sheet against an attack consisting of Charlie Austin and Jay Rodriguez tells its own story!

I wasn't quick slating him at all, we all know Hudson has been shit in the league these last few games.

Do we

Do we

Again, I still find it unbelievable that this guy gets as much stick as he does!

Well a lot of people I been talking to saying he hasn't been playing good, I agree with them aswell. Give Blake a chance with Gerrard when he comes back from injury, hope it's not too long

Do we

Again, I still find it unbelievable that this guy gets as much stick as he does!

He prob does make more mistakes than most but I reckon he does more defending than any other cb. His positional play is excellent, his covering top class. If he had pace he would be in the prem.

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

He makes a lot of blocks, again positioning though.
I think the main problem with huds and Gerrard is they get turned way to easily and have no mobility in either of them.
Gerrard better in the air but gets lost easily.

Do we

Again, I still find it unbelievable that this guy gets as much stick as he does!

He prob does make more mistakes than most but I reckon he does more defending than any other cb. His positional play is excellent, his covering top class. If he had pace he would be in the prem.

I think the mistakes are less frequent nowadays, but I agree with everything else.

No-one can moan though, a player can only give 100%. Although we all moan now and then

turner is the rock in our defence need to find a partner for him i personally believe blake is perfect for turner

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

His positioning/anticipation/reading of the game helps him make crucial interceptions though, which are usually with his feet. Gerrard's heading is probably stronger, but Huds is pretty strong in that department anyway.

So you want him dropped because of form then, and not his ability?

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

His positioning/anticipation/reading of the game helps him make crucial interceptions though, which are usually with his feet. Gerrard's heading is probably stronger, but Huds is pretty strong in that department anyway.

So you want him dropped because of form then, and not his ability?

Well surely, if a player isn't on form, he wouldn't be able to use his ability/fullpotential that well. As apposed to Blake, he has a lot of ability and is on-form with Wales, played great in Leicester game but needs a lot more game-time to keep that up

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

His positioning/anticipation/reading of the game helps him make crucial interceptions though, which are usually with his feet. Gerrard's heading is probably stronger, but Huds is pretty strong in that department anyway.

So you want him dropped because of form then, and not his ability?

Well surely, if a player isn't on form, he wouldn't be able to use his ability/fullpotential that well. As apposed to Blake, he has a lot of ability and is on-form with Wales, played great in Leicester game but needs a lot more game-time to keep that up

Yeah I agree with the form/ability point. I forgot they both go together

Forgive me, it's late

Well the way I see it is he is much better defending with his head than his feet. And yeah he's not very fast and the Titanic could turn quicker than him, but he hasn't been at the top of his game recently, unfortunately

His positioning/anticipation/reading of the game helps him make crucial interceptions though, which are usually with his feet. Gerrard's heading is probably stronger, but Huds is pretty strong in that department anyway.

So you want him dropped because of form then, and not his ability?

Well surely, if a player isn't on form, he wouldn't be able to use his ability/fullpotential that well. As apposed to Blake, he has a lot of ability and is on-form with Wales, played great in Leicester game but needs a lot more game-time to keep that up

Yeah I agree with the form/ability point. I forgot they both go together

Forgive me, it's late

i thought hudson was outstanding tonight and close to being MoM

gerrard would of been very exploited if it wasnt for hudson covering for him

as for heaton marshal, its a coin toss when there both in form

Heaton in goals against Leeds

Chuck Naylor in for Leeds can he repeat for us?

Heaton all day long... and i'd want to see Gerrard and Turner have a few games together to see what they can do

he made two class saves expecially the fingertip one from the volley early in the game so why not give him a chance

Remember Marshall in West Ham
Remember Heaton in Middlesbrough
Yes they were a while back but i'm always more confident with Marshall in goals

David Marshall remember in play off final

David Marshall remember in play off final

Yes but West Ham was more recent, play off final season was 2 years ago

ye but we could have been in prem by now but he was rubbish

Well we could've been in the prem and back in the championship

Remember Heaton at Preston on Easter Monday?

Remember Heaton at Preston on Easter Monday?

Yes, was that the time he went f*cking nuts? And yeah top class fair play