Goodwillie V Miller

All this debate about who the better buy would be

All i know is Miller has being doing it for the past 10 years and goodwillie has the potential to do it

For me miller wins hands down.he scored 21 goals in 18 games before he departed for turkey.Hes 31 so what!!!!!!!Miller bangs em in for fun.left foot,right foot or the head and he dosent come with an injury list either.....

There is no question that if miller gets the supply then we are looking at 25 goals from him!!!!!!!!!!!!

miller

Im happy with miller,would like to see goodwille here aswell

experience, proven goal scorer - miller
exciting young prospect, guaranteed goals - goodwillie

I thought Miller had 5 in 15 from Turkey grant you thats not a bad retrun... if where looking for potential and going forward I think id plum for Goodwillie if he came off resale value alone would be pushing 5 million..... but looks like thats not happening

Miller, definitely. Goodwillie is too much of a gamble for that valuation.