Malky. On a scale of 1-10

How happy are you with his appointment ?

8/10 for me.

Young, ambitious, media friendly, gained promtion 3 times at this level as a player.

Exciting times ahead

10 for me....gives him a bit of room to feck up once or twice!

10 easy.

just because he shows PASHUN

10 for me - passion

8.7 for me

10

10

10 - he's a young ambitious and hungry Manager.

Good Luck to MM's Barmy Army

9 for me!

9 for me, he seems da boss!

After listening to his interview, it's a 9 for me, I will give him a 10 if he gets us promoted

But you can tell he will take no nonsense and he will bring in players with the right character and passion for the club. We have been a soft touch for too long but I believe we won't be anymore under Mackay. What a difference to Jones, I was unsure at first, but his interview has completely changed my opinion, i'm very excited and can't wait to see what signings he will make!

After listening to his interview, it's a 9 for me, I will give him a 10 if he gets us promoted

But you can tell he will take no nonsense and he will bring in players with the right character and passion for the club. We have been a soft touch for too long but I believe we won't be anymore under Mackay. What a difference to Jones, I was unsure at first, but his interview has completely changed my opinion, i'm very excited and can't wait to see what signings he will make!

Is the interview online?

After listening to his interview, it's a 9 for me, I will give him a 10 if he gets us promoted

But you can tell he will take no nonsense and he will bring in players with the right character and passion for the club. We have been a soft touch for too long but I believe we won't be anymore under Mackay. What a difference to Jones, I was unsure at first, but his interview has completely changed my opinion, i'm very excited and can't wait to see what signings he will make!

Is the interview online?

Here you go mate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlqVpk2qkcU

After listening to his interview, it's a 9 for me, I will give him a 10 if he gets us promoted

But you can tell he will take no nonsense and he will bring in players with the right character and passion for the club. We have been a soft touch for too long but I believe we won't be anymore under Mackay. What a difference to Jones, I was unsure at first, but his interview has completely changed my opinion, i'm very excited and can't wait to see what signings he will make!

Is the interview online?

Here you go mate: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RlqVpk2qkcU

cheers mate

10 for passion
5 for contacts
couldn't comment on squad building ability that is one thing dave jones had regardless what anyone says.. he did ofcourse lack the qualities to back up the squads

me as well

but i dont like what he did to watford though seems harsh...
and a bit of a shock to them...

mcleish was worse mind the birmingham lads must be well fuckin pissed lolol

I'll give him a 1 for now purely because i seriously thing there are better managers available out there for us.

Hopefully im wrong....

I'll start giving him points when I see improvements....

9 or 10

As for the poster who gave him 1. Watch some football mate.

8/10