Cardiff City Forum



A forum for all things Cardiff City

WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 2:37 pm

If he does he will do a middlesbrough in my opinion.

Like Strachan, he came in and brought all these scotish players with him and it really spelled a disaster.

If McInnes gets the job, i can see him doing this aswell :roll:

Alot of scotish players cannot face it in the english divisions.

does anyone agree?
or am i just being harsh? :lol:

:ayatollah: :ayatollah:

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 2:39 pm

Bit harsh, Owen Coyle did ok didnt he :ayatollah:

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 2:41 pm

Think you are being harsh Chief. He might not do that but remember we have super Kev, Quinny Marshall, We had several Scottish players over the years that was quality. Just because Strachan is shite does not mean all Scottish Managers are the same. Alex Ferguson !!!!!

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 2:42 pm

Nuclearblue wrote:Think you are being harsh Chief. He might not do that but remember we have super Kev, Quinny Marshall, We had several Scottish players over the years that was quality. Just because Strachan is shite does not mean all Scottish Managers are the same. Alex Ferguson !!!!!


I just feel that the scotish division is alot weaker in my opinion

yes, fergie and coyle are doing fantastic, but i'd rather have someone with experience in the english division.. and also he's only managed for 3 or 4 years

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 2:54 pm

glammy74 wrote:If he does he will do a middlesbrough in my opinion.

Like Strachan, he came in and brought all these scotish players with him and it really spelled a disaster.

If McInnes gets the job, i can see him doing this aswell :roll:

Alot of scotish players cannot face it in the english divisions.

does anyone agree?
or am i just being harsh? :lol:

:ayatollah: :ayatollah:


I think they are valid points to be fair. But Strachan is just shite full stop!

Perhaps someone like McInnes would be better served starting in the first
or second division where a lot of the Scottish Premier players would stand
out more, then building up their network of scouts/contacts etc.

But again, there are exceptions to every rule. If he's given the job there
will be very good reasons why he's been given the nod ahead of people like
Hughton and I doubt they will all be financial!

I have faith

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 3:44 pm

taffyapple wrote:
I think they are valid points to be fair. But Strachan is just shite full stop!

Perhaps someone like McInnes would be better served starting in the first
or second division where a lot of the Scottish Premier players would stand
out more, then building up their network of scouts/contacts etc.

But again, there are exceptions to every rule. If he's given the job there
will be very good reasons why he's been given the nod ahead of people like
Hughton and I doubt they will all be financial!

I have faith


Yeah strachan was shit :lol:

Re: WHY I HOPE DEREK MCINNES DOESNT GET THE JOB

Mon Jun 06, 2011 3:52 pm

He might buy Loovens,Ledley and Matthews!! :lol: :lol: :lol: