Who would you rather Earnshaw/ Or Jay B

Lets be honest earnshaws goal last night was world class and if he was Brazalian we'd be seeing repeats of it for years , if you look at his stats he has made 389 appearance in total for various clubs and scored 164 goals which is a fantastic record. He is now aged 30. In comparison Jay is 28 and has made 304 appearance and has scored 75 goals. For me personally if we could have a choice of the 2 strikers I would offload Jay he looked lazy and lacklustre since Christmas , In comparison look at earnie's work rate and endeavour and I still think could do a job for 2 seasons.

Earnie without a shadow of a doubt

Difficult to say considering that they play two totally different positions, what is in no dought is that earnie would run through a brick wall for cardiff city where as the waste of space jay didn,t even break a sweat for the club since november!!!!!!

if a manager got bobthroyd back to his best that would be a quality partnership i think

very different players

both would be great together

Earnie for me. Knows what it means to play for the badge on his chest. Wouldn't mind both together though!

I would get Earnie back here in a heartbeat (especially if he's free!)

He possesses pasion and determination - something that is sadly lacking at our club at the moment!
OK - He's not the best in the world and he's getting on now, but he still has the pace and technical ability to do some serious damage in the championship, add that to the element of team spirit he'll bring with him.......

We've seen the effect that Bellamy has had on Cardiff City - and with Earnie as well - the belief will start to ignite amongst the fans and players again!

Obviously we need to strengthen in Midfield (as we funnily enough said this time last year!) but he is one addition that can make a difference.

chopra / bellamy/ parkin/ earnie would be an excellent choice for strikers. maybe throw in tyson to

EARNIE

We couldnt afford any of them rite now so its a pipe dream atm

No doubt it would be Jay

Lets be honest earnshaws goal last night was world class and if he was Brazalian we'd be seeing repeats of it for years , if you look at his stats he has made 389 appearance in total for various clubs and scored 164 goals which is a fantastic record. He is now aged 30. In comparison Jay is 28 and has made 304 appearance and has scored 75 goals. For me personally if we could have a choice of the 2 strikers I would offload Jay he looked lazy and lacklustre since Christmas , In comparison look at earnie's work rate and endeavour and I still think could do a job for 2 seasons.

neither,lets move on,new blood

Lets be honest earnshaws goal last night was world class and if he was Brazalian we'd be seeing repeats of it for years , if you look at his stats he has made 389 appearance in total for various clubs and scored 164 goals which is a fantastic record. He is now aged 30. In comparison Jay is 28 and has made 304 appearance and has scored 75 goals. For me personally if we could have a choice of the 2 strikers I would offload Jay he looked lazy and lacklustre since Christmas , In comparison look at earnie's work rate and endeavour and I still think could do a job for 2 seasons.

neither,lets move on,new blood

But your happy with Parkin right?

ernie for free fantastic signing

Lets be honest earnshaws goal last night was world class and if he was Brazalian we'd be seeing repeats of it for years , if you look at his stats he has made 389 appearance in total for various clubs and scored 164 goals which is a fantastic record. He is now aged 30. In comparison Jay is 28 and has made 304 appearance and has scored 75 goals. For me personally if we could have a choice of the 2 strikers I would offload Jay he looked lazy and lacklustre since Christmas , In comparison look at earnie's work rate and endeavour and I still think could do a job for 2 seasons.

neither,lets move on,new blood

But your happy with Parkin right?

parkin a good utillity player,someone to have on the bench to change a game

ernie for free fantastic signing

Earnie by a mile. I would love to see him back,,,,,,,sooner rather than later.

Sir Robert Earnshaw for me

Lets be honest earnshaws goal last night was world class and if he was Brazalian we'd be seeing repeats of it for years , if you look at his stats he has made 389 appearance in total for various clubs and scored 164 goals which is a fantastic record. He is now aged 30. In comparison Jay is 28 and has made 304 appearance and has scored 75 goals. For me personally if we could have a choice of the 2 strikers I would offload Jay he looked lazy and lacklustre since Christmas , In comparison look at earnie's work rate and endeavour and I still think could do a job for 2 seasons.

neither,lets move on,new blood

parkin a good utillity player,someone to have on the bench to change a game

And how many games did you see him change exactly? Apart from one decent Norwich goal - he's been a bit pants really!!

sorry,how much game time did he get.when bothroyd was out on his feet or flat on his arse after 60 minutes why was parkin not brought on until the 85th minute,parkin gave away freekicks but won some valuable ones for us

sorry,how much game time did he get.when bothroyd was out on his feet or flat on his arse after 60 minutes why was parkin not brought on until the 85th minute,parkin gave away freekicks but won some valuable ones for us

i agree with you mate

for the clubs sake and jays. he needs a fresh start. hes just going through the motions here

Earnie he's got passion for this club up

sorry,how much game time did he get.when bothroyd was out on his feet or flat on his arse after 60 minutes why was parkin not brought on until the 85th minute,parkin gave away freekicks but won some valuable ones for us

and how much game time did Earnie get against Swansea - before scoring? and how many times as he done this in the past!

If Earnie WANTS to come back - #Hereinaflash!

sorry,how much game time did he get.when bothroyd was out on his feet or flat on his arse after 60 minutes why was parkin not brought on until the 85th minute,parkin gave away freekicks but won some valuable ones for us

and how much game time did Earnie get against Swansea - before scoring? and how many times as he done this in the past!

If Earnie WANTS to come back - #Hereinaflash!

yep,you said it"in the past",time to move on

But your happy with Parkin right? [/quote]
parkin a good utillity player,someone to have on the bench to change a game [/quote][/quote]

Before Parkin came here I rated him but to be honest he has been awful since he arrived and I've seen no evidence of him coming off the bench to change games! I'm hoping that with a pre season behind him and a few more 90 minutes u der his belt he will improve but right now I'm seriously underwhelmed

Earnie....he has passion for the club