"ARE THE PLAYERS LETTING US DOWN AGAIN ? ? "

Annis will all of the players names involved be in the echo tomorrow?

I dont know as at the moment its being put down as an unprovoked attack by one man and the club are saying he came over for no reason and attacked Marshal.

Does sound like a much more likely scenario, obviously don't know what happened but I'd find that version easier to believe.

Ok thanks for that, so its now David Marshal that got head butted.........?

Richard, It was Def Marshal who got attacked and yes Marshal might be innocent and the bloke had the wrong player.

That bloke must be crazy, have you seen the size of David Marshal. Id have slapped him and run like f**k

Apparently the bloke was a Boxer and was a hell of a size himself.

Cardiff is a village, when it comes to a story and in the end nothing can be kept secret.[/quote]


Some people will read into things from different angles and some people will never see the truth or facts, they have that kind of mindset. All I can say is thank god it wasnt before the Reading game, saying that if it was we could understand our failings.

Seasons over so they are entitled to go out, what do we expect them to do? stay in for the next 3 months!! people get in arguements/fights no big deal just happens to be CCFC involved.......again!

I hope Cardiff doesn't end up like Newcastle, in regards to being a total goldfish bowl where every single one of their actions is watched and scrutinised by everyone around.

Seasons over so they are entitled to go out, what do we expect them to do? stay in for the next 3 months!! people get in arguements/fights no big deal just happens to be CCFC involved.......again!

I hope Cardiff doesn't end up like Newcastle, in regards to being a total goldfish bowl where every single one of their actions is watched and scrutinised by everyone around.

I have to agree with you on this

Ive seen Marshall out in a pub on Jan 2nd watching the Celtic v Rangers game and he seemed a decent enough guy to me , didnt see him drink all that much altho he did have his Scottish family with him .

Deano, The Echo are going run this story, so how is it not Carls finest hour ?

Players names have been edited by me and that is for legal reasons.

Carl has ONLY STATED FACTS.

Because he got names wrong and associated innocent people with bad behaviour?

You did not know who was innocent and yes the other players were there, but as yet we dont know which players could be guilty .

By naming players who were present, in a story about our players 'letting us down again' without being 100% sure of who was to blame for the alleged incidents is just Shit stirring, whether by Carl or the Echo! And it probably wasn't the best idea to be out that night, but thats hardly a crime is it?

Seasons over so they are entitled to go out, what do we expect them to do? stay in for the next 3 months!! people get in arguements/fights no big deal just happens to be CCFC involved.......again!

I hope Cardiff doesn't end up like Newcastle, in regards to being a total goldfish bowl where every single one of their actions is watched and scrutinised by everyone around.

I have to agree with you on this

STOP THE PRESS!!!!!!!

Annis, we've agreed on something!!!!

Seasons over so they are entitled to go out, what do we expect them to do? stay in for the next 3 months!! people get in arguements/fights no big deal just happens to be CCFC involved.......again!

I hope Cardiff doesn't end up like Newcastle, in regards to being a total goldfish bowl where every single one of their actions is watched and scrutinised by everyone around.

I have to agree with you on this

STOP THE PRESS!!!!!!!

Annis, we've agreed on something!!!!

If this guy is a boxer then he needs to give Nathan Cleverly a call pronto just incase he cant find an opponent for tomorrow nite

Wouldn't this all be on cctv?

Wouldn't this all be on cctv?

To be fair Carl has only stated the facts as Annis has said.There seems to be all sorts of differing stories going on here.Stick with the facts and let's remember assumption is the mother of all f**k up's.

Deano posted
This post has definitely not been Carl's finest hour I'm afraid......The players weren't the only ones who had a bad end of season






Really?


its not the clubs finest hour again, and not for the first time this season.,

Because he got names wrong and associated innocent people with bad behaviour?

You did not know who was innocent and yes the other players were there, but as yet we dont know which players could be guilty .

By naming players who were present, in a story about our players 'letting us down again' without being 100% sure of who was to blame for the alleged incidents is just Shit stirring, whether by Carl or the Echo! And it probably wasn't the best idea to be out that night, but thats hardly a crime is it?

Deano where have I accused any of players of wrong doing. I have stated an incident took place and that is correct, the club have even admitted it. I have asked a question of the players.


You have made a statement that it was not the best idea for the players to be out on the said night but how dare I put out a fact and then ask a question on it.

Fair play

Why would there be a problem of them being out Wednesday night, atleast this time round it didnt intervere with any games.

Why would there be a problem of them being out Wednesday night, atleast this time round it didnt intervere with any games.

Richard, I agree, No problem with them being out

just a problem with conduct.

Why would there be a problem of them being out Wednesday night, atleast this time round it didnt intervere with any games.

Richard, I agree, No problem with them being out

For a change they got their timing right

Mud always sort of sticks where Cardiff City or its fans are concerned.

this season has been like a dream team script maybe we should change our name to Harchester United?

huge clear out is in order.

disgusting if true. we need to get rid of some of them, causing trouble and problems within the camp. get rid of them!

disgusting if true. we need to get rid of some of them, causing trouble and problems within the camp. get rid of them!

HAS ANYONE ONE WOKE MARSHALL UP YET ?

disgusting if true. we need to get rid of some of them, causing trouble and problems within the camp. get rid of them!

HAS ANYONE ONE WOKE MARSHALL UP YET ?

probably stays home and makes different accounts on the message boards because he has nothing else to do!

huge clear out is in order.

Def agree with that, away with the lot of them

Just out of Curiosity Carl, is this the only forum reporting this incident?

Someone mentioned on CCMB that a group of City players were "on the piss" in St.David's 2, but no mention of any incident.

If they were innocent how come they were the ones asked to leave and not the boxer? (unless the staff were too scared to kick him out )

Bound to be ccvtv evidence I would've thought.

Ive seen Marshall out in a pub on Jan 2nd watching the Celtic v Rangers game and he seemed a decent enough guy to me , didnt see him drink all that much altho he did have his Scottish family with him .

I have met all the players breifly and out of all of them I would say Marshall comes across the best and most down to earth, in fact most of them are ok......

One or two which I wouldn't name, but it would not suprise me if they got headbutted but Marshall that would be a shock as he comes across as a very decent nice bloke IMO....

And don't forget these players could be minding their own business, but started on by some dickhead, we are all City fans and should no more than anyone else that trouble can find you even when you are not looking for it..........

Marshall was in the gym training this morning with McPhail.
If he caught a headbutt wednesday night it wasnt a very good one cos I didnt notice any bruises.

Marshall was in the gym training this morning with McPhail.
If he caught a headbutt wednesday night it wasnt a very good one cos I didnt notice any bruises.

Perhaps he caught it ???? First time for anything i suppose

Marshall was in the gym training this morning with McPhail.
If he caught a headbutt wednesday night it wasnt a very good one cos I didnt notice any bruises.

Perhaps he caught it ???? First time for anything i suppose

As I pressed submit, I realised what a bad choice of words that was!!!

Marshall was in the gym training this morning with McPhail.
If he caught a headbutt wednesday night it wasnt a very good one cos I didnt notice any bruises.

I spoke to someone from the Club and Marshal was Def the one attacked and they are 100% Saying he was the Innocent one and I actually believe them on this