Cardiff City Football Forum | Cardiff City FC Messageboard

Useless tonight.

Warnock is giving him dirty looks he is gone thankfully.

One trick pony should try using his right foot now and again. Need at least 8 players in the window imo

Dreadful performance. He's a shadow of the player who got promoted to the premiership. He needs to go along with Pilkington. Well beaten tonight which shows the gap needed in quality to gain promotion next year. But given the dreadful start to the season I am just pleased that tonight doesn't really matter.

EastleighBlue wrote:Dreadful performance. He's a shadow of the player who got promoted to the premiership. He needs to go along with Pilkington. Well beaten tonight which shows the gap needed in quality to gain promotion next year. But given the dreadful start to the season I am just pleased that tonight doesn't really matter.

Didn't think they were that special Newcastle tonight. However they do have that quality in the team and that is what you need when you can't break down a defence.

If Craig Noone put away one of those chances we could hae got something from that game.

Fair play to him he gives you 110% but needs to move on now.

Bakedalasker wrote:

EastleighBlue wrote:Dreadful performance. He's a shadow of the player who got promoted to the premiership. He needs to go along with Pilkington. Well beaten tonight which shows the gap needed in quality to gain promotion next year. But given the dreadful start to the season I am just pleased that tonight doesn't really matter.

Didn't think they were that special Newcastle tonight. However they do have that quality in the team and that is what you need when you can't break down a defence.

If Craig Noone put away one of those chances we could hae got something from that game.

Don't forget mangas free header too!

Noone been useless for years not just tonight.

missed two sitters tonight think we know what happens next

He's still has more end product than Harris

Winter purple patch, i'd gladly let them both leave

Noone and Pilkington can leave tonight, joined by Witts (sorry but time is up)and they can be joined by Hoilett (based on his showing tonight). Halford is not fit and will Harris ever be able to cross a ball? Looks like we need at least 6 players. Other than that things could be worse!!

I have for a while felt Noone could come back and it was confidence but tonight he was dreadful very poor plus Pilks too

I thought pilks did ok when he came on. Funny how others see it differently. Noone whitts manga all gone. Halford is very poor player. Gunnar should be the player sat in front of centre backs. Why I
Has warnock changed this?

When he came on Hoilett switched sides so Noone could play on the right yet again.

Why do they do that? Craig Noone is a professional footballer,playing one division down from the top league in this country, earning (allegedly) a salary upwards of £20,000 per week and he can only kick a football with one foot

And he's not the only one. Whittingham, Ralls and Zohore might as well not wear boots on their right feet as they do absolutely everything they can to get the ball onto their left foot.

Noone currently having approximately one to two good games per season. Wolves away last season, Derby away this season.

Another one who's time is up.

One of the worst players to wear the blue cloth and to think were paying this chimp £20k a week, I know a few non league players who'd play out of their skin and score 10 fold more than Noone for £2k a week !!

nubbsy wrote:

Bakedalasker wrote:

EastleighBlue wrote:Dreadful performance. He's a shadow of the player who got promoted to the premiership. He needs to go along with Pilkington. Well beaten tonight which shows the gap needed in quality to gain promotion next year. But given the dreadful start to the season I am just pleased that tonight doesn't really matter.

Didn't think they were that special Newcastle tonight. However they do have that quality in the team and that is what you need when you can't break down a defence.

If Craig Noone put away one of those chances we could hae got something from that game.

Don't forget mangas free header too!

Noone been useless for years not just tonight.

Jack ,he's never lived up to the pre-purchase hype! I recall we chased him for some time and Brighton were desperate to keep him...or were they, if you know what I mean? LOL

nubbsy wrote:

Bakedalasker wrote:

EastleighBlue wrote:Dreadful performance. He's a shadow of the player who got promoted to the premiership. He needs to go along with Pilkington. Well beaten tonight which shows the gap needed in quality to gain promotion next year. But given the dreadful start to the season I am just pleased that tonight doesn't really matter.

Didn't think they were that special Newcastle tonight. However they do have that quality in the team and that is what you need when you can't break down a defence.

If Craig Noone put away one of those chances we could hae got something from that game.

Don't forget mangas free header too!

Noone been useless for years not just tonight.

And Zohores header as well as Morrison having goal disallowed which on screen underneath at half time didn't look too much wrong with it.

Noone offers the side next to nothing and he will be lucky to find a league 1 club on the form he is showing.

Warnock mumbled 'f*****g, rubbish', seemed to be aimed at noone's miss at the back post, where he had to adjust to his favoured left, rather than just using his right foot

boyo1927 wrote:I thought pilks did ok when he came on. Funny how others see it differently. Noone whitts manga all gone. Halford is very poor player. Gunnar should be the player sat in front of centre backs. Why I
Has warnock changed this?

Halford was a complete toss pot the worst individual performance this season IMO. In fairness he wins a number of headers in centre field but he never finds a blue shirt. Also easily beaten on the ground and does nothing going forward.

That said he offers than Noone

Both noone and pilks are like headless chickens

Morrison is lost without bamba to many mistakes and not closing down quick enough

Charlie Harper wrote:Noone offers the side next to nothing and he will be lucky to find a league 1 club on the form he is showing.

he has had good games, or at least good spells in some games which seem to gloss over the 90% of absolute garbage the rest of the time. he is willing to try but that in no way makes up for not having the football nous to be in the right areas or knowing himself what exactly he is ..trying..to do.
met him a couple of times ,really nice guy but in my view has done well to remain at this level for so long.

gwentbluebirds wrote:
And Zohores header as well as Morrison having goal disallowed which on screen underneath at half time didn't look too much wrong with it.

I agree and I think NW needs to give KZ another 'pep' talk as he should have buried that header. IMO Morrison's goal should have stood the ref was a total gob shite.

dogfound wrote:

Charlie Harper wrote:Noone offers the side next to nothing and he will be lucky to find a league 1 club on the form he is showing.

he has had good games, or at least good spells in some games which seem to gloss over the 90% of absolute garbage the rest of the time. he is willing to try but that in no way makes up for not having the football nous to be in the right areas or knowing himself what exactly he is ..trying..to do.
met him a couple of times ,really nice guy but in my view has done well to remain at this level for so long.

That's a good summary CN does flatter to deceive for short periods in games but the total sum of his contribution is just about zero.

Got the distinct impression half the team were already on their jollies

I wish i had the mins to goals and assists because i would wager Nooney contributes more than both Holiett and Harris put together. Never really been a fan of his, or that type of player

All three can go for me.

llan bluebird wrote:I wish i had the mins to goals and assists because i would wager Nooney contributes more than both Holiett and Harris put together. Never really been a fan of his, or that type of player

All three can go for me.

my coments were confined to Noone, dont get me started on Kadeem.
Hoilett im not sure, you might well be correct about goals and assists, but i feel he understands the game better than both those 2 put together and wastes less.

Jules wrote:Got the distinct impression half the team were already on their jollies

I think Noone and Whittingham just wanted to get the game out of the way so they could hit Mill Lane last night, where I saw them at around 3am.

dogfound wrote:

llan bluebird wrote:I wish i had the mins to goals and assists because i would wager Nooney contributes more than both Holiett and Harris put together. Never really been a fan of his, or that type of player

All three can go for me.

my coments were confined to Noone, dont get me started on Kadeem.
Hoilett im not sure, you might well be correct about goals and assists, but i feel he understands the game better than both those 2 put together and wastes less.

I'm pretty sure Harris has more goals and assists than Noone and Hoilett put together this season.

Tonteg Bluebird wrote:

dogfound wrote:

llan bluebird wrote:I wish i had the mins to goals and assists because i would wager Nooney contributes more than both Holiett and Harris put together. Never really been a fan of his, or that type of player

All three can go for me.

my coments were confined to Noone, dont get me started on Kadeem.
Hoilett im not sure, you might well be correct about goals and assists, but i feel he understands the game better than both those 2 put together and wastes less.

I'm pretty sure Harris has more goals and assists than Noone and Hoilett put together this season.

I think your right. He definitely has more than noone.