Fri Jul 15, 2016 7:23 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:07 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:16 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:28 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:28 am
Reza wrote:If we sell Marshall who do we go for? Hennessy??
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:49 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:52 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 8:53 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 9:13 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 9:34 am
bluebird58 wrote:Will we get the money to buy new players? If so, then snap their hand off because that's twice what he's worth. Nowhere near the player he was 2 years ago and Moore is a capable keeper, especially with a run of games. For £6m you get a couple of players that would score 30 goals a season between them. Swapping Moore for Marshall might cost you 10 goals a season at most.
Fri Jul 15, 2016 9:52 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 9:56 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 9:56 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:02 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:05 am
Forever Blue wrote:bluebird58 wrote:Will we get the money to buy new players? If so, then snap their hand off because that's twice what he's worth. Nowhere near the player he was 2 years ago and Moore is a capable keeper, especially with a run of games. For £6m you get a couple of players that would score 30 goals a season between them. Swapping Moore for Marshall might cost you 10 goals a season at most.
A question to you, Do you think we will get the money for new players?
I don't.
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:23 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:24 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:38 am
Forever Blue wrote:bluebird58 wrote:Will we get the money to buy new players? If so, then snap their hand off because that's twice what he's worth. Nowhere near the player he was 2 years ago and Moore is a capable keeper, especially with a run of games. For £6m you get a couple of players that would score 30 goals a season between them. Swapping Moore for Marshall might cost you 10 goals a season at most.
A question to you, Do you think we will get the money for new players?
I don't.
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:47 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 10:56 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 11:09 am
tylorstown18891 wrote:Like all the other transfer windows?
Fri Jul 15, 2016 11:19 am
Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Fri Jul 15, 2016 11:36 am
davids wrote:Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Sven,
On what basis do you believe that the club has ambition for the coming season (other than to stay in the division of course)?
What evidence have you seen that the club is making a genuine and concerted attempt to get promoted?
Fri Jul 15, 2016 11:55 am
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:28 pm
to truenubbsy wrote:tylorstown18891 wrote:Like all the other transfer windows?
Yeah and all the next ones!
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:39 pm
davids wrote:Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Sven,
On what basis do you believe that the club has ambition for the coming season (other than to stay in the division of course)?
What evidence have you seen that the club is making a genuine and concerted attempt to get promoted?
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:46 pm
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:53 pm
Sven wrote:davids wrote:Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Sven,
On what basis do you believe that the club has ambition for the coming season (other than to stay in the division of course)?
What evidence have you seen that the club is making a genuine and concerted attempt to get promoted?
It's all a matter of perspective and opinion...mine being positive and others being negative (often at all costs)![]()
My personal opinion is that the club would have kept Russell Slade on, if they were 'happy' with where we finished last year. But they didn't; they moved him out and brought in Paul Trollope. Some of us moaned initially (I certainly did) but what I've seen since has encouraged me. He had a great Euro 2016, he is getting the backroom staff right, he is shifting some of the deadwood out (who would have thought Malone would go?) and he is apparently looking to bring some positive players in. Jazz Richards is a good example of that
I guess we'll only see once the season kicks off but the early signs are that our glass is currently half full rather than half empty; that, however, is a matter of perspective and I'd rather turn up at the CCS feeling positive than negative like many so-called fans who only seem to have a downer on all things Cardiff City these days
I know I'd rather turn up at the CCS in August with an air of positivity. What's the point of going otherwise?
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:54 pm
Sven wrote:davids wrote:Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Sven,
On what basis do you believe that the club has ambition for the coming season (other than to stay in the division of course)?
What evidence have you seen that the club is making a genuine and concerted attempt to get promoted?
It's all a matter of perspective and opinion...mine being positive and others being negative (often at all costs)![]()
My personal opinion is that the club would have kept Russell Slade on, if they were 'happy' with where we finished last year. But they didn't; they moved him out and brought in Paul Trollope. Some of us moaned initially (I certainly did) but what I've seen since has encouraged me. He had a great Euro 2016, he is getting the backroom staff right, he is shifting some of the deadwood out (who would have thought Malone would go?) and he is apparently looking to bring some positive players in. Jazz Richards is a good example of that
I guess we'll only see once the season kicks off but the early signs are that our glass is currently half full rather than half empty; that, however, is a matter of perspective and I'd rather turn up at the CCS feeling positive than negative like many so-called fans who only seem to have a downer on all things Cardiff City these days
I know I'd rather turn up at the CCS in August with an air of positivity. What's the point of going otherwise?
Fri Jul 15, 2016 12:57 pm
Sven wrote:davids wrote:Sven wrote:We can never be sure at our club but I'd be surprised if there is any mileage in a 'Marshall to Hull' deal
Firstly, this would cause issues come November when McGregor comes back from his injury; when it would clearly create friction between two very ambitious Scots internationally. Only one of them would be able to claim Hull's No.1 spot and the other would be restricted Reserve Team games and (by default) cast into the international wilderness
Secondly, if Cardiff City FC have any ambition for this coming season (and I believe they do) then that won't be served well by getting rid of the most consistent player we have had at our club for many a year. Moore isn't at the same level (yet) and how much do we think it would cost too bring another similar standard 'keeper in? About what we'd sell one for, of course!
Finally, Marshall (we keep repeating this) is happy in Cardiff with his family and is not actively seeking to leave the CCS anytime soon
Sven,
On what basis do you believe that the club has ambition for the coming season (other than to stay in the division of course)?
What evidence have you seen that the club is making a genuine and concerted attempt to get promoted?
It's all a matter of perspective and opinion...mine being positive and others being negative (often at all costs)![]()
My personal opinion is that the club would have kept Russell Slade on, if they were 'happy' with where we finished last year. But they didn't; they moved him out and brought in Paul Trollope. Some of us moaned initially (I certainly did) but what I've seen since has encouraged me. He had a great Euro 2016, he is getting the backroom staff right, he is shifting some of the deadwood out (who would have thought Malone would go?) and he is apparently looking to bring some positive players in. Jazz Richards is a good example of that
I guess we'll only see once the season kicks off but the early signs are that our glass is currently half full rather than half empty; that, however, is a matter of perspective and I'd rather turn up at the CCS feeling positive than negative like many so-called fans who only seem to have a downer on all things Cardiff City these days
I know I'd rather turn up at the CCS in August with an air of positivity. What's the point of going otherwise?